"You—"
His knees buckled.
The colonel fell from the saddle.
Silence swept across the ridge.
Voss looked down at the body.
Then toward Calder.
For the first time, the captain's face showed genuine fear.
He turned his horse.
And fled west.
Calder watched him disappear into the canyon.
Then he urged Solomon forward.
Because some ghosts could not be allowed to escape again.
Elias Voss rode as though the devil himself pursued him.
His horse thundered through the narrow canyon, hooves striking sparks from the stones. Dust rose behind him in thick clouds.
Calder followed at a distance.
His wounded shoulder burned.
Every movement sent pain through his chest.
But he kept riding.
The canyon narrowed.
Voss glanced backward.
He saw Calder.
Then he laughed bitterly.
"Still chasing ghosts, Van?"
Calder said nothing.
He urged Solomon forward.
Voss fired over his shoulder.
The bullet struck the canyon wall.
Stone fragments scattered.
Calder ducked.
Solomon stumbled but recovered.
The trail climbed toward a narrow ledge overlooking Black Canyon.
Voss reached it first.
He turned his horse.
Raised his revolver.
And waited.
Calder slowed.
The two men faced each other beneath the rising sun.
For a moment, the years seemed to vanish.
Calder saw the battlefield again.
The smoke.
The dead horses.
The wounded boys calling for water.
Voss smiled.
"You never learned."
Calder dismounted.
His left arm hung uselessly.
He held his revolver in his right hand.
"Get off the horse."
Voss laughed.
"Why?"
"Because this ends here."
The captain studied him.
"You're wounded."
"Yes."
"Exhausted."
"Yes."
"And you still believe you can defeat me?"
Calder looked toward the canyon.
"I don't need to defeat you."
Voss frowned.
"I need you to stop running."
The captain's expression hardened.
He dismounted.
The two men stood twenty feet apart.
Wind moved between them.
Voss glanced toward Calder's injured shoulder.
"You should have killed me in the mine."
"Perhaps."
"Mercy made you weak."
Calder shook his head.
"No."
He looked directly at Voss.
"Mercy kept me from becoming you."
Voss's face twisted.
He drew.
Calder fired.
The shot struck Voss's revolver, knocking it from his hand.
The captain cried out.
He stumbled backward.
Calder stepped forward.
"It's over."
Voss stared at his bleeding hand.
Then at Calder.
For one moment, he seemed defeated.
Then he lunged.
A knife flashed from his sleeve.
Calder tried to step aside.
The blade cut across his ribs.
Pain exploded.
He struck Voss with the revolver.
Both men fell.
They rolled across the rocky ground.
The knife skittered toward the edge.
Voss seized Calder's throat.
His face was twisted with hatred.
"You should have died in that valley!"
Calder struggled for breath.
He drove his knee upward.
Voss grunted.
His grip loosened.
Calder shoved him away.
The captain staggered toward the ledge.
Loose stones crumbled beneath his boots.
He lost his balance.
For one terrible instant, he hung above the canyon.
Then he caught a root protruding from the rock.
Calder crawled toward him.
Voss stared upward.
"Help me!"
Calder stopped.
The canyon dropped hundreds of feet below.
Voss's fingers slipped.
"Calder!"
The name echoed.
Calder remembered forty-seven dead soldiers.
His father.
Elan.
Thomas.
The graves beneath the mountain.
He could let go.
No one would blame him.
Perhaps no one would ever know.
Voss stared at him.
"Please."
Calder closed his eyes.
Then he reached down.
"Give me your hand."
Voss seized his wrist.
Pain tore through Calder's shoulder.
He cried out.
But he held on.
Slowly, he pulled the captain toward the ledge.
Voss scrambled onto solid ground.
For a moment, both men lay gasping.
Then Voss reached for the fallen knife.
Calder saw the movement.
He rolled aside.
The blade struck stone.
Calder seized Voss's wrist.
They struggled.
The captain snarled.
Then the knife slipped from his fingers.
It fell into the canyon.
Calder struck him once.
Hard.
Voss collapsed.
This time, he did not rise.
Calder sat beside him, breathing heavily.
Blood soaked his shirt.
His shoulder throbbed.
But the captain was alive.
And for the first time in twelve years, Calder felt the past loosen its grip.
He looked toward the sky.
The sun had risen above the red cliffs.
The desert stretched endlessly beyond them.
Calder closed his eyes.
Then he whispered, "It's over."
Behind him, hoofbeats approached.
Naya appeared at the canyon entrance.
She saw Calder sitting beside the unconscious captain.
Her face changed.
She dismounted and ran toward him.
"Calder!"
He looked up.
A tired smile crossed his face.
"You're late."
She dropped to her knees beside him.
Then she laughed through her tears.
"You impossible man."
He reached for her hand.
And this time, neither let go.
The investigation began three days later.
Territorial officers entered Echo Hollow with lanterns, shovels, and notebooks.
Eleanor Price accompanied them.
So did Daniel Van.
Calder remained in Miriam's care, recovering from his wounds.
Naya returned to the northern settlement to help identify the dead.
The burial chamber was opened carefully.
Each grave was documented.
Each body examined.
Personal belongings were collected and recorded.
The evidence was overwhelming.
Rifles bearing army markings.
False invoices.
Payments to hired gunmen.
Land deeds signed under coercion.
And beneath a stone marked with a crude cross, investigators discovered the original ledger Elan had hidden.