Jim, Leo said. "Thank you for not taking it."
Jim swept. "Thank you for being worth not taking it from," he said, and would not say one word more, all the way to six o'clock.
Cat Sullivan came back on Wednesday, early, before the shop had finished waking up. She had a diner coffee in one hand and her hair still had the shape of sleep in it, and she looked, Leo thought, like somebody who had been awake since before the light. She asked Frank — not Jim, Leo noticed; people were careful, this week, about what they asked Jim — if somebody could start the FXR for her.
I want to hear her with no crowd, she said. "Just the once. Before Saturday, when everybody's here and she's a — an exhibit."
Frank wiped his hands and did it himself, and did it respectfully, the way you'd light a candle in somebody else's church. The FXR turned over once, twice, caught — and the sound filled the shop the way it always did, up into the rafters where the old banners hung, and Cat Sullivan stood in front of her father's motorcycle with her eyes closed and her hands loose at her sides, listening with her whole body.
She sounds different, Cat said, while it ran. "Different from how I remember."
Different how? Frank said.
Softer at the bottom. She used to *surge* a little when you asked her for more. Like she was arguing with the road. She listened another moment. "Now she just — goes."
She runs gentle now, Leo said. "Dad did that. On purpose."
Cat looked at him then, over the running engine, the way you look at a child who has said something too big for the room — but the engine was running, and she didn't ask, and Leo didn't explain, and Frank, who knew what the boy meant, kept his eyes on his work.
When Frank cut the engine, the silence had a shape to it, the way it does when a song ends in a room where people loved the singer.
Cat stepped forward and laid her palm flat on the tank, over the tiny scratches, the way you'd touch the face of somebody sleeping to be sure of them. She left it there a long time.
He talked to this bike, she said at last, to Leo mostly, because Leo was standing at her elbow being eight at her with all his might. "Full conversations, Leo. Not mumbling — *conversations*. 'Morning, old girl. Don't embarrass me today.' He'd tell her about the weather like she was deciding whether to go. My mother used to say he had two wives and one of them was better at keeping secrets."
Leo laughed before he could help it, and Cat smiled sideways, and it aimed them both at each other like the start of something.
Did she ever answer? Leo asked.
Once a year she did, I think. Cat's hand moved on the tank, once, the way you'd smooth a tablecloth. "He kept a photograph in the saddlebag. In a little oilskin pouch, so the rain couldn't get it. He never showed it to me — not once, in thirty-four years. I'd ask, when I was little, and he'd say, 'Some pictures are just for the road, baby.' It's still in there, far as I know. I haven't opened that saddlebag since — " She stopped. "Since the spring. I keep meaning to. Then I don't."
Leo thought about the photograph in the oilskin pouch, riding in the dark of the saddlebag all these years. He thought about his own tag in his pocket. The shop, this week, was full of things fathers had hidden inside the machines and the leather, and the children finding them one by one like eggs at Easter, except nobody was laughing.
What about the dawn thing? Leo asked carefully. "Frank said. Every year. The anniversary."
Cat looked at him then, really looked, with her father's eyes. "You know about that."
Frank told me. He said nobody asked more than once.
Frank's right. She leaned against the workbench, and her voice went into the register of telling-true-things, which Leo was learning to recognize the way you recognize a key change. "Every year, one morning in the fall, I'd wake up and the house would have that *already been awake* feeling. He'd be gone. Bike gone. He'd come back by breakfast smelling of cold air and woodsmoke from somebody's early fire, and he'd be quieter all day — not sad, exactly. Quieter. Like a bell after it's rung. When I was fourteen I finally asked him where he went. You know what he said? 'Some rides are just visiting, Cat.' That's all I ever got. Fourteen words on it in twenty years, and I counted."
Visiting who? Leo asked.
That's the question, isn't it. Cat looked at the FXR. "There's a fourth man in all the old pictures, Leo. Did you know that? Dutch, Jim, your dad — and a fourth one, blond, laughing in every single picture like the camera owed him money. There's one where he's got Dad in a headlock and Jim's falling off a cooler, and your dad's the only one looking at the camera. Like he knew. He's in the album from before I was born, and then he just — stops being in them. Nobody ever captioned him. When I was a kid I thought he moved away."
Leo's hand went, without asking him, to his shirt pocket.
His name was Eddie Brennan, Leo said. "He died on the mountain. The year — a long time before I was born. Dad put his name in the bike. I found it."
Cat went very still. It was a different stillness from Jim's — not frightened; struck. Like a note sounding in a room she hadn't known had a piano in it.
Eddie Brennan, she said, testing it. "He had a *name*."