You rode behind Eddie, she said. It wasn't a question, and it wasn't an accusation. It was a door she was holding open with both hands.
Jim looked at her for a long time. He was a big man gone soft at the edges, with forty years of friendship in his face, and Leo had never seen him afraid the way he'd been afraid of a piece of metal the size of a postage stamp — and now Leo watched the fear change into something else, something older, as Jim Mercer finally, after twenty-seven years, stepped through the door.
I rode behind Eddie, Jim said. "I always rode behind Eddie. He was the better rider and we both knew it, and I liked watching him ride. He made it look like the road was doing him a favor."
He spoke slowly, to the workbench, to the letter, to the middle distance where 1998 was.
I saw Dutch's brake light come on and stay on, and I saw him sit up — a man sits up like that when the lever comes back to the bar and there's nothing in it. I heard him shout. And Eddie— Jim's voice went, briefly, and he let it go and waited for it to come back, and Leo understood that this was a thing Jim had practiced never saying for twenty-seven years and was now saying without practice. "Eddie didn't even look back. He just went. Knew what was needed and went and did it, the way he did everything — you remember, Cat, he was three years gone before you were old enough to—" He shook his head. "No. You were a kid. You don't remember him. That's part of it too. He died and then we stopped saying his name, and a whole person got—" He stopped again.
I was first down to the roadside, Jim said. "That's mine. I've never told that to a living soul, including your mother, Sarah, including the priest I don't have. I was first to him. And I've wondered for twenty-seven years whether being first is why I couldn't ever say it — like I'd been handed something down there that I was supposed to carry up and hand over, and instead I just — kept carrying it. Past Dutch. Past the rebuild. Past every anniversary ride where I followed that man up the mountain at dawn and watched him stand at the overlook saying a name to nobody, and I stood behind him with the name in my mouth like a stone, and I swallowed it, every year, because we swore, because his heart, because Tuesday."
His hands came up off the bench and hung in the air, empty.
For twenty-seven years, Jim said, "I have ridden behind Dutch Sullivan. Every ride. Rain, cold, chapter runs, funerals of men who were never on that mountain. I told myself it was loyalty — some of it was. But some of it was a man keeping watch on a brake light, waiting for it to come on and stay on, so that this time I'd be close enough to do Eddie's job better than Eddie got to do it. I'd give back every one of those miles to tell Dutch the one thing he may never have known: that I was back there on purpose. That somebody was always back there on purpose."
I believe my silence hurt my friends as much as those brakes hurt Eddie, Jim said. "Not the same way. Worse in one way: the brakes only did it once. I did it every year for twenty-seven years. Arthur carried it to his grave. Dutch carried it alone after he'd figured it out, which is the part I can't — we were protecting a man who'd already done the hardest part by himself, in the dark, and never told us, because we'd taught him the subject was closed. That's what the quiet did. It closed subjects."
Nobody spoke. The letter lay on the bench. Outside the locked door, the evening traffic went past on the boulevard, ordinary as mercy.
Cat stood up.
She crossed the little distance between them — Dutch's daughter, thirty-four years old, who had ridden two states through the night to lead her father's memorial ride — and she took Jim's hands in both of hers, and held them, and looked at him the way Leo's father must have looked at an engine he refused to give up on.
Uncle Jim, Cat said — and Leo saw Jim's whole face change at the name, a name from when Cat was small and the world had four friends in it — "Dad knew. He knew, and he still had you ride behind him every single year, and he still called you first when the bike wouldn't start, every spring of his life. Whatever you carried up that mountain, he never once asked you to put it down — but he never blamed your hands for holding it, either."
You were first to him, she said. "You've carried that like it was the worst part. Uncle Jim — somebody who loved him was the first one to him. If it couldn't be any other way, that's the way I would have prayed for it to be."
Jim Mercer wept then, standing at the workbench where he had stood for forty years, with his dead friend's daughter holding his hands so they would stop shaking.
Leo watched, and did not look away, because some sounds a person has to finish making, and some sights too. The tag hung on its cord against his chest, warm as a coal, and for the first time since he'd found it, it didn't feel like a secret.
It felt like a message that had finally been delivered.
The shop was quiet in the way it only ever was after hours, when the lifts were down and the radios were off and the day's noise had settled into the concrete. The letter lay open on the workbench where Cat had put it down, and nobody seemed willing to be the first to fold it away.