Christmas morning was harder, because Christmas had rules. There were stockings, and there was music, and there was a tree with lights that Andrew had put up himself, carefully, as if care could fill the room. Lily opened her presents and thanked him, and she did not ask about cards, because she had already asked once, and Andrew had said that Christmas cards never came, that her mother had chosen not to send them, that some things were too painful for Emma to face.
"Birthdays are too painful for her," he had said, and Lily had wanted to ask painful for whom, but she had not, because the sentence had been delivered with such certainty that questioning it felt like being unkind.
At school, in the counselor's office, Lily sat with her hands in her lap and answered questions about how she was doing. She said she was fine. She said school was fine. She said home was fine. The counselor nodded and wrote something down, and Lily watched the pen move and wondered what fine looked like on paper. She did not say that she checked the mailbox sometimes, when her father was not looking, and found it locked. She did not say that she had once, at the beginning, expected a letter every day, and then every week, and then had stopped expecting, because stopping hurt less than hoping.
The quiet doubt grew anyway, in the way doubts do when they are not fed by answers. It grew when Ms. Alvarez, her teacher, paused a little too long over a returned card, and when a classmate mentioned a mother who had written from far away, and when Lily remembered that her mother had never once, in her whole life, forgotten a birthday.
Silence, Andrew had taught her without quite saying it, was proof. If her mother loved her, she would have called. If her mother cared, she would have written. Lily repeated that logic to herself on the nights when she missed her mother most, because logic was supposed to make feelings smaller. It did not. It only made her feel guilty for missing someone she had been told had chosen to go.
She did not know about the letters behind the rear panel. She did not know about the mornings before sunrise. She knew only that the mailbox at the end of the driveway was locked, and that her mother, who had never missed bedtime, had somehow missed everything since. At night, she sometimes stood at her bedroom window and looked down the driveway toward that box, wondering what it would feel like to open it herself. She never tried. Her father kept the key, and asking for it would have meant a conversation she was not ready to have, about a mother she was not supposed to keep missing so loudly.
Three people held one harmless piece each, and none of them knew it was a piece.
The old neighbor lived two streets over, in a house with a garden she still tended herself. She had received a letter from Emma in the early months, addressed in Emma's familiar hand, asking her to pass a message to Brooke if she saw her, and to tell Lily, if she ever saw Lily, that her mother loved her. The neighbor had read it twice, had put it in a drawer, and had not known what to do with it.
It was not that she did not care. She cared, and that was the problem. Passing on a message from a woman who had left her husband felt like taking a side, and taking a side felt like interfering in a marriage she did not fully understand. She told herself she would do it when she saw Brooke, and then she did not see Brooke, and then weeks passed, and the letter stayed in the drawer, becoming older and less urgent with each passing day, until it felt strange to bring it up at all. When she finally heard about the axe, she opened the drawer and held the envelope in her hands, and she understood, with a sickening clarity, that a harmless piece, kept too long, could become part of a wall.
Ms. Alvarez remembered the returned cards differently. She had been Lily's teacher, and she had watched Lily grow quieter over the months, in the way children do when they are carrying something too large to name. Twice, cards addressed to Lily had come to the school, and twice they had been returned, because the address on file was no longer correct, or because someone had said not to forward school mail to a home address that had changed. Ms. Alvarez had filed the returns, had made a note, and had felt a small unease she could not quite justify.