Everyone thought the blonde woman with the axe was crazy — until the missing wife’s letters fell out of the mailbox

Chapter 3

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"Waiting for what?" Andrew said again, because he could not leave the sentence unfinished.

"For someone in this neighborhood to stop pretending they don't know your wife didn't just leave."

Andrew's face changed. It was not a large change. His jaw tightened, his eyes narrowed, and something careful moved behind them, the way a man recalculates when a conversation stops going the way he planned. Across the street, Mrs. Collins stepped onto her porch in a bathrobe, her arms folded against the cold, and stood watching without speaking.

"There it is," the woman said quietly.

"You need to leave," Andrew said.

"No."

"This has nothing to do with you."

"My sister is your wife."

Silence fell on the street. It was the kind of silence that makes ordinary sounds louder: the drizzle on the maple leaves, the sprinkler clicking, the dog at the corner shifting its weight. Andrew looked at her properly for the first time, past the axe and the muddy boots and the denim jacket, and recognition came over him in a slow, unwelcome wave.

Brooke Nolan. Emma's younger sister. The woman who had never liked him, not from the first dinner, not from the first time he had walked into a room and felt her watching him the way a person watches something they do not trust. The woman who had asked too many questions after Emma disappeared, who had kept calling detectives long after other people had stopped calling, who had stood in this same driveway months ago and asked him things he had answered with a calm he did not feel.

He had described her, carefully and repeatedly, as unstable. He had said it to friends, to family, to anyone who would listen, in the same even tone he used for everything else. He had said it so often that it had become part of the story of Emma's disappearance, a small, useful fact that explained why Brooke would not stop.

"Brooke," he said, "this is not helping your case."

"My case?" she said. "You mean the case nobody wanted to open because you kept telling everyone Emma was depressed?"

"She was struggling," Andrew said.

"She was scared."

"She left."

"She wrote."

His jaw tightened further. He could feel Mr. Collins watching, and Mrs. Collins, and Dana Whitfield at the corner, and he knew that every word he said now was being stored away by people who had, until this morning, believed the version of events he had given them.

"Brooke, this is not the way," he said, lowering his voice, trying to recover the calm that had always served him. "Whatever you think happened, destroying my property is not going to bring Emma back."

"I'm not trying to bring her back with an axe," Brooke said. "I'm trying to open the thing you locked her inside."

She pointed the axe at the mailbox, not at him, but the gesture was clear enough. "And every time she wrote, you got here first."

Andrew did not answer. He could not find an answer that did not sound like an admission, and so he stood in his socks on his wet lawn, with his neighbors watching, and said nothing at all. He thought of Brooke as she had been at Emma's wedding, younger and louder than her sister, laughing too hard at the reception, and then as she had been in the weeks after Emma vanished, standing on his porch with questions he had answered by shaking his head and looking tired. He had told himself then that she would tire herself out, that grief made people persistent for a while and then made them quiet. She had not gone quiet. She had gone methodical, and he had mistaken the change for defeat because it was easier than admitting she was still working. Mrs. Collins shifted on her porch, pulling her bathrobe tighter, and Andrew was aware of her watching him in a new way, not with sympathy but with attention, as if she were revising something she had long believed. He wanted to tell her, and Mr. Collins, and Dana Whitfield, that this was a family matter, that Brooke did not understand, that Emma's leaving had been complicated and sad and private. But the words would not arrange themselves, because Brooke had just named the one fact he could not explain away: that a wife who wrote had been treated, in this house, as a wife who had never written at all. The drizzle thickened for a moment, pattering on the maple leaves, and Andrew felt the wet seeping into his shirt, cold against his skin, while Brooke stood with the axe in her hands and waited for him to say something true.

News in the same category

Everyone thought the blonde woman with the axe was crazy — until the missing wife’s letters fell out of the mailbox

45 Part