"To make you an offer. A clean one." He set the ribbon down, and his smile didn't reach his eyes. "Mr. Quill can draw up an annulment — quick, quiet, no scandal. A marriage of a few weeks, unconsummated by all accounts —" he let that hang in the air like smoke — "the judge will grant it before lunch. You sell me the farm, water rights and all. I'll clear every debt your father left, and put two hundred dollars cash in your hand besides." He smiled. "No charity. No debts repaid by other people's guilt. You'd be free, Wren. Truly free. Isn't that what you came to town to find?"
Her hands had gone cold. Two hundred dollars. The debts gone. No more wondering, in the dark of Mabel's spare room, whether any look Gus had ever given her was meant for her or for a ghost.
It was everything she'd told herself she wanted.
"Why?" she said.
"Why what?"
"Why do you want that farm so badly? It's played out. The house is falling down. You've said so yourself."
Something flickered in his polished face, too fast to catch. "Water, my dear. Your land sits on the best water in the valley. That's all. Commerce."
She thought of Gus, sitting on his porch till dark. She thought of the compass in her bag, and the words cut into the brass. Find your way home.
"I'll think about it," she said.
That evening she told Mabel everything, sitting on the edge of the narrow bed with her tea going cold.
Mabel listened the way good friends do — without interrupting, without fixing — and then she said, "Pride is a fine horse, Wren, but it'll throw you if you ride it blind."
"I'm not being proud. I'm being practical."
"Honey, you moved to town and started keeping a ledger of what you owe a man who never once asked to be repaid. That's not practical. That's pride wearing practical's coat." Mabel took her hand, her fingers smelling of lavender water and chalk. "Now listen to me about Voss. A man doesn't offer two hundred dollars cash for a played-out farm out of commerce. He wants that water because it's worth ten times that. And here's what I know about Harlan Voss: he only ever offers you the choice he thinks you'll take. Ask yourself why he's so sure you'll take this one — and then ask yourself who benefits if you do."
Wren didn't sleep that night. She lay awake doing sums that wouldn't balance, and in the morning she did what she always did when sums wouldn't balance: she went to look at the figures herself.
The land office clerk was a bored young man with ink on his cuffs who, for a fifty-cent fee, would show anyone anything. Wren asked to see the Halloran file — her father's farm, the debts, all of it — and he sighed and fetched a folder tied with tape.
She'd come to check the debt figures for her ledger. What she found instead stopped her breath.
The water-rights transfer. Dated fourteen months ago. Signed, in a flowing, confident hand: Thomas Halloran.
Wren stared at it until the letters blurred.
Her father had signed his name "Thos. Halloran" his entire adult life — she'd watched him do it a hundred times on seed orders and church pledges. And in his last two years, after the stroke, his hand had shaken so badly he could barely hold a pen; his signature had been a trembling scrawl that wandered off the line.
This signature was smooth as poured cream. And it spelled out Thomas in full.
Her father had never signed his Christian name out in full in his life.
"He didn't sign this," she said quietly.
The clerk glanced over. "Ma'am?"
"This is forged." Her voice was steady, though her hands weren't. "I want a certified copy. Now, please."
She paid the dollar fee with money she'd earned hemming Mrs. Abernathy's — no, Mabel's customers' — dresses, and she folded the copy into her bodice, and she walked out of the land office into the white noon glare feeling like the ground had shifted under her feet and settled into something solid.
Voss hadn't just wanted her land. He'd stolen it — or tried to — with a pen. And he'd offered her two hundred dollars to walk away from the proof.
She hired a livery horse and rode for Broken Spur at a gallop, the copy crackling against her ribs with every stride.
Gus was at the corral fence when she rode in, and he went still the way he had at the depot that first day — utterly, completely still — and then he was moving toward her, and she was off the horse before he'd reached her, and she pulled the folded paper from her bodice and thrust it at him.
"Read it," she said. "The signature."
He read. She watched his face change — the slow, dawning comprehension, then the cold fury settling in like winter.
"Thos.," he said. "He always signed Thos."
"And his hand shook for two years before he died. This is a young man's writing, Gus. Voss forged it. Or had it forged." Her voice caught. "He offered me an annulment yesterday. Two hundred dollars cash to sell him the farm and walk away. He wanted me gone before I ever looked at this."
Gus looked from the paper to her face, and something in his own face cracked open — relief, and shame, and a hope he was afraid to touch.
"Wren—"
"I'm not here because I forgive you," she said quickly. "I'm not here because of my mother, or your debt, or any of it. I'm here because that man tried to rob my father with a pen, and I need —" She stopped. Started again, quieter. "I need a partner, Gus. Not a creditor. Not a debtor. A partner. Can you be that?"
He held the forged copy in one big hand, and with the other he reached out — slowly, giving her every chance to step back — and took her hand.
"I've been trying to be," he said. "Since the day you proposed to me at that depot. I just didn't know how to say it without it sounding like another debt."
She didn't step back.
"Then we'll say it with work instead," she said. "Starting now. Together."
"Together," he agreed.