"Not Lydia's daughter," he said. "Not a debt. Not a promise I made to a ghost. You. I love you, Wren. I've loved you since you beat Pete at cards with three queens and laughed like the house was on fire — which, at the moment, it is."
She stared at him. Smoke stung her eyes. Somewhere behind them Mrs. Abernathy was making a sound like a teakettle.
"Say something," Gus said.
Wren Halloran — who had proposed marriage to a stranger at a train depot with terms and conditions, who had faced down Harlan Voss in his own bank, who had not cried since she was eight years old — took his burned hand in both of hers, laced her fingers through his, and held on.
She didn't let go for a long time.
The hearing was held in Sycamore on the first Tuesday of December, in the back room of the land office, because the courthouse roof had blown off in the November storms and nobody in the territory moved fast enough to fix it before winter.
Wren had expected something grander. Instead there were twelve chairs, a potbellied stove, a clerk with ink on his cuffs, and a federal magistrate named Judge Parrish who had ridden in from the capital with snow on his shoulders and impatience in every line of his face. Harlan Voss sat at the front in a suit that cost more than most men's horses, with Mr. Quill beside him looking like a man who had swallowed something sharp. Eddie Cobb sat behind Gus with his arms crossed and his rifle — by special permission of the magistrate — leaning against the wall. Pete, his hands still bandaged, sat next to Mrs. Abernathy, who had brought a basket of biscuits for no reason anyone could determine and was sharing them with the clerk.
Wren sat beside Gus. He held her hand under the table where no one could see, and didn't let go.
The magistrate laid out the matter with the briskness of a man cutting wood: the Halloran water rights, the disputed transfer, the foreclosure proceedings, the fire. Then he nodded to the young federal attorney, who stood and began, piece by piece, to take Harlan Voss apart.
The forged signature came first. Wren's evidence — her father's true hand set beside the transfer document, the loops wrong, the pressure wrong, the "H" formed by a man imitating rather than writing — was laid before the magistrate alongside the testimony of the bank clerk Voss had bribed to witness it. The clerk, a thin young man with a sick mother and a thinner conscience, had confessed everything the week before in exchange for leniency, and he sat in the back row now with his hat in his hands, unable to meet Voss's eyes.
Then the arsonist — dragged in from the county jail, still smelling of smoke — described the fifty dollars, the coal oil, and the orders passed through Mr. Quill's office.
Then Mr. Quill himself stood up.
Wren would remember that moment all her life: the weaselly little lawyer rising, smoothing his waistcoat with trembling hands, and turning to face the man who had paid him for ten years.
"Mr. Voss instructed me," Quill said, his voice cracking, "to prepare the transfer with a forged signature, to bribe the witnessing clerk, and to arrange the destruction of the Broken Spur barn when the Halloran woman refused to sell. I have kept copies of his letters. I am prepared to surrender them."
The room went very still. Voss's face had gone the color of old paper.
"Traitor," Voss said softly.
"Prudent," said Quill.
Judge Parrish took off his spectacles and cleaned them, a gesture Wren would later learn meant he had already decided. He looked at Wren over the rims.
"Mrs. Marlowe," he said — and the name, her married name, spoken with respect in a room full of men, steadied her like a hand at her back. "You identified the forgery. In your own words, for the record — how did you know?"
Wren stood. Her knees shook, and she locked them, and thought of Lydia walking into a mining camp with her head up.
"My father wrote his H's like fences," she said. "Two posts and impatience between them. He never lifted the pen. On that transfer, the H is drawn — lifted, set down, drawn again. That's not writing. That's copying." She paused. "He was a weak man, Judge. But his hand was his own. Nobody else gets to use it."
The magistrate nodded slowly, and made a note, and Wren sat down to Gus's hand finding hers under the table again, warm and certain.
"Mr. Voss," Judge Parrish said, "this court finds the water-rights transfer fraudulent and void. The rights revert to the Halloran estate in full. The foreclosure proceedings are dismissed. You will face federal charges of fraud, arson conspiracy, and attempted murder. Bail is denied."
It was over that quickly. Twelve years of Voss's slow tightening around her father's land, ended in twelve minutes by a tired magistrate with snow melting off his boots.
Outside, the December air was sharp and clean. Pete whooped and threw his bandaged hands in the air and immediately regretted it. Mrs. Abernathy wept into her handkerchief and claimed it was the cold. Eddie shook the federal attorney's hand hard enough to hurt him. And Gus stood on the land-office steps with Wren's hand in his, looking out over the little town of Sycamore, and laughed — one short, surprised sound, like a man who'd forgotten he knew how.
Voss was led past them in irons. He stopped, and looked at Wren with something that might have been hatred and might have been respect.
"You were supposed to marry me, girl," he said. "It would have been easier."
"I know," Wren said. "That's why I didn't."
They watched him go. And then Gus did something Wren didn't expect: he let go of her hand, reached into his coat, and brought out the old tin box — the one with the woman's letters tied in ribbon, the one he'd closed so quickly in the ranch office all those months ago.
"It's time," he said quietly. "Read them. All of them. Then I'll tell you the rest."