He Bought Every Pie Before Sunset. By Dawn, She Learned Why He Had Really Come

Chapter 3

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

“You could have told me.”

“I could not risk your reaction.”

“My reaction?”

“Rusk has spent twenty years believing you know nothing. I needed him to see surprise on your face.”

Clara slapped him.

The sound cracked through the darkness.

Caleb accepted it without flinching.

“You deserved to know,” he said. “But the plan depended on you not knowing.”

Another bullet struck the stone.

Dust sprayed across them.

Caleb took Clara’s hand and pulled her toward a trapdoor.

“There is a tunnel beneath the mill.”

They dropped into darkness as the front doors burst open.

The camera of the imagined scene plunged with them, following their descent through rotting beams and earth, then rushed forward as they crawled through the narrow tunnel beneath the mill.

Above, boots thundered.

Rusk shouted orders.

Caleb pushed open a hatch at the tunnel’s end.

Moonlight spilled across the riverbank.

They emerged behind a wall of reeds.

A horse waited nearby.

Caleb helped Clara mount, then swung up behind her.

They rode hard toward town.

Wind tore at Clara’s hair.

“Why are we going back?” she shouted.

“Because Rusk will burn the church first.”

The realization hit her.

The final pie.

They reached Red Creek as flames appeared beyond the rooftops.

The church bell began ringing wildly.

Clara and Caleb galloped into the square.

Father Daniel stood outside the church, struggling with a man who held a kerosene can.

Caleb leaped from the saddle and tackled the man.

Clara ran inside.

Smoke drifted through the nave.

The pie sat on the altar.

She rushed toward it.

A hand grabbed her from behind.

Sheriff Rusk dragged her backward and pressed a revolver beneath her jaw.

“You always were your father’s daughter,” he whispered.

Clara froze.

Caleb entered the church and stopped.

Rusk tightened his hold.

“Drop the gun.”

Caleb obeyed.

The revolver struck the floor.

Rusk laughed bitterly.

“Silas should have stayed gone.”

“You killed him?” Clara asked.

“I tried.”

His breath smelled of whiskey and smoke.

“He found the deeds. Thought truth mattered more than survival. I shot him by the river, but he escaped. After that, I kept you under my roof. He knew what would happen if he returned.”

Clara’s eyes filled with tears.

“You told me you loved me like a daughter.”

“I did.”

Rusk’s voice softened with something almost sincere.

“That was the inconvenience.”

He aimed at the pie.

“Now tell me where the records are.”

Caleb looked at Clara.

The smallest movement passed through his face.

A warning.

Clara understood.

She began to laugh.

Rusk stiffened.

“What is funny?”

“You are too late.”

His grip tightened.

“You think the papers in that pie will save you?”

“No.”

Clara looked toward the church doors.

“The papers were never in the pies.”

Caleb’s eyes widened.

This time, his surprise was real.

Rusk spun Clara around.

“What did you say?”

She smiled through her fear.

“My father knew Rusk watched everything,” she said, looking at Caleb now. “But he also knew strangers could be followed.”

Caleb stared at her.

“I found the letter in my father’s coat years ago. Hidden in the lining. I thought it was nonsense until you brought the button.”

Rusk’s face drained of color.

Clara continued.

“The ledgers were never meant to travel out of Red Creek. The pies were a diversion.”

“Where are they?” Rusk demanded.

Clara’s gaze lifted toward the ceiling.

Above them, the church bell rang again.

Father Daniel had reached the rope outside.

“The bell,” Clara said.

Rusk looked up.

Inside the hollow bronze bell, hidden for twenty years, were the original ledgers.

Her father had concealed them before fleeing.

And every year, on the anniversary of his disappearance, Clara had unknowingly helped Father Daniel polish that bell.

Rusk shoved her aside and ran toward the stairs leading to the tower.

He made it three steps.

The church doors opened.

Men in dark coats entered, rifles raised.

At their front stood a gray-haired federal marshal.

Behind him came the circuit judge, two newspaper editors, and townspeople carrying lanterns.

The marshal spoke calmly.

“Amos Rusk, you are under arrest for murder, land fraud, bribery, and conspiracy against the territory.”

Rusk turned toward Caleb.

“You said noon.”

Caleb smiled faintly.

“I lied.”

Rusk reached for his gun.

Clara kicked the back of his knee.

He fell.

The marshal’s men rushed forward and seized him before he could fire.

For several seconds, Clara could hear nothing but her own breathing.

Then the tension inside her broke.

She sank onto a pew.

Caleb approached slowly.

“You knew about the bell?”

“Not until tonight.”

“How?”

Clara opened her father’s envelope.

She had taken it from the mill before the shooting began.

Inside was a single page.

My dearest Clara,

If Caleb finds you, trust his courage but not his plans. He believes he is delivering my evidence. He does not know he is delivering my son.

Clara read the line twice.

Then she looked at Caleb.

He had gone pale.

“No,” he whispered.

Clara continued reading.

Caleb is your brother.

The church seemed to fall silent around them.

Caleb stepped backward.

“My father told me I was an orphan.”

“You were,” Clara said, tears filling her eyes. “But not in the way you believed.”

News in the same category

He Bought Every Pie Before Sunset. By Dawn, She Learned Why He Had Really Come

7 Part