windlass and to his temper. He examined the windlass then, carefully, by feel and by light: the handle loosened at its joint, the rope frayed partway through in a place that would have looked like wear to a man in a hurry, and a tool mark on the stone where something heavy had been levered. It was damage meant to fail later, not now, and Corvin understood the cruelty in that choice. A man who breaks a well outright can be blamed at once. A man who weakens it can watch his enemy draw water, day after day, waiting for the day it fails, and call it bad luck. Corvin tightened what he could by lantern light and resolved to repair it properly at dawn, because a well is not a thing you leave half-mended, any more than a fence is.
Hosa returned from the gully then, having followed the raiders only as far as the place where their tracks joined the Copperton trail, and no farther, because following men into strange ground at night is how a watchman becomes a casualty. He brought back the dropped tool the raiders had left — a common pry bar, nothing marked, nothing that would name a man by itself — and he laid it beside the cut rope on the fence rail, so that the night's leavings were gathered in one place for Marsh to see. He also brought back the direction, fixed and certain: the raiders had run north first, as they had before, then bent east, the same line, the same habits, the same men. Corvin listened, and thought about Marsh's warning, and about how a man who has been warned and still keeps his watch is a different man from one who is merely frightened. He had been frightened on the morning of the three hundred riders. He was not frightened now. He was tired, and angry, and determined, and those were steadier things to stand on.
When the yard was quiet again, Corvin picked up the page by lantern light, and Hosa stood beside him, breathing hard, as they read it together. It was a ledger page, in a rough, hurried hand, listing horses taken — six, from Corvin's corral, by number and description — and beside the list, a payment, entered plainly, from Calloway. The hand, Corvin would later learn, was Grady Pike's, the foreman who did Calloway's dirty work and kept accounts of it the way a careless man keeps accounts of everything. Corvin folded the page carefully, as if it were something fragile, which in a way it was: a single sheet of paper that tied a burned hay store, a cut fence, and a dead young man on a hunting trail to one name, written in the hand of the man who had carried out the orders. He looked at Hosa, and Hosa looked back, and neither man smiled, because there was nothing to smile about yet. But the watch had held, the well still stood, the horses were still in the corral, and the raiders had left behind the one thing they could not afford to leave: their own writing, in their own hand, on Corvin's ground. The page was proof, and proof, Corvin knew, was what would finally hold Calloway.
The evidence table was Corvin's kitchen table, cleared of everything except a lamp, four chairs, and the papers that would decide whether a town believed a rancher or a rustler. Sheriff Marsh sat at one end with his own notebook open, Tom Becker sat beside him, Sani sat across from Corvin, and Edna Cole — who had ridden out from Copperton that morning with Marsh, carrying her store's trade records wrapped in oilcloth — sat at the far end, looking as if she had no intention of letting anyone hurry her through her books. Outside, Hosa kept watch at the fence, and the ranch went about its morning business in the background: horses shifting, wind moving, the well drawing clean water as if the night's damage had never happened, though Corvin had repaired the windlass himself at first light and knew exactly where the frayed rope had been.
Marsh laid out the case piece by piece, the way a man lays out tools before a job, and each piece was named aloud so that no one could later say it had been hidden or assumed. First, Pike's ledger page, dropped at the well during the second raid, in Pike's hand, listing the six horses taken from Corvin's corral and a payment from Calloway beside the list. Corvin read the horse descriptions aloud, and Becker confirmed them, horse by horse, because he had seen those animals in Corvin's corral and knew them. Second, the cut piece of corral rope from the first raid, with the false markings and the town knots, laid beside a true knot Hosa had tied that morning for comparison, so that Marsh could see the difference with his own eyes and not merely take Sani's word for it. Sani explained the knots again, patiently, and Marsh nodded as he compared them, because a sheriff who has seen a forgery beside the real thing does not easily forget the difference.
Third, Edna Cole opened her trade records, and her part of the table was the quietest and, in some ways, the most damning. Page by page, in her neat storekeeper's hand, she showed purchases Calloway had made in Copperton: horses bought, paid for, and entered in her books as his — horses he had never owned, horses that matched, by description and by date, the animals taken from Corvin's corral and from Sani's people's hunting party. A ledger does not flatter anyone, Edna said. Marsh studied the dates, compared them with Corvin's notebook and with Pike's page, and the three sets of dates lined up the way honest records line up when they are all telling the same story from different rooms. Becker added his testimony then, about Calloway's questions concerning the well, his talk of abandonment, and his boast in the store that the Torne well would be his by autumn, and Marsh wrote it down in full, in Becker's presence, so that it stood as a witnessed statement and not as gossip.