"Walk me through it again," Rachel said. It was the third time that week.
"From the watch."
Tom told it the way he'd told it to Marsh, to the DA, to the grand jury: the
vibration at 2:17, the hands over the fence, the blue swimsuit, the pouch, the
syringe, the towel, the confrontation, the tablet, the four feeds, the 911 call.
Rachel listened without taking notes — she knew it by heart — and when he
finished she said, "Good. Boring. Keep it boring. Boring is credible."
On the center monitor, a technician named Dev was syncing the five angles
into a single timeline. Four camera feeds — street, side gate, rear fence, pool
— plus Chloe's phone video, all time-stamped, all aligned to the second. Dev
played it for Tom: 2:17:04, the motion alert; 2:18:31, hands over the fence;
2:19:02, Diane dropping onto the grass; 2:20:15, the pouch opening; 2:20:41,
the syringe catching the light; 2:21:03, her hand under the towel; 2:21:04, her
hand coming back empty. And in the fifth angle, Chloe's window: Diane's
face in close-up, the fear flashing and then the coldness settling over it like
ice on a pond.
"Porter says she found the syringe and panicked," Rachel said. "Watch her
hands."
Dev froze the frame at 2:20:41. Diane's hands were steady. Deliberate. The
hands of a woman doing something she had planned.
"Panicked people drop things," Rachel said. "They don't pouch them."
The pharmacy footage was cued next: Diane at the counter two days before,
buying a box of syringes, paying with her loyalty card — the loyalty card
that gave her ten cents off and gave the prosecution a receipt with her name
on it. The parking-lot camera showed her loading the bag into her car. The
63
same car she'd driven to the lake house that morning. The same lake house
where, in framed photos on the mantel, the waterproof pouch sat on a shelf
behind her in three separate pictures.
"The vet-sedative expert is locked," Rachel said. "Dr. Anand — he'll testify
the residue is consistent with a large-animal sedative, enough to knock a man
out cold, and that Diane has no animals, no prescription, and no legitimate
reason to possess it."
"And the tox screen?" Tom asked.
"Yours came back clean. Which kills their other theory — that you were
using and she found your stash." Rachel capped her marker. "They don't have
a theory, Tom. They have a woman in a swimsuit and a prayer."
Chloe's decision came on a Sunday evening, in the kitchen, while Tom was
burning garlic bread.
"I want to testify," she said.
Tom turned around so fast he nearly dropped the pan. "No."
"Yes."
"Chloe —"
"She should have to hear it." Chloe stood in the doorway with her camera
around her neck, and her voice didn't shake, and that scared Tom more than
tears would have. "That's what you said about the cameras. That the truth
should be seen. I saw her, Dad. From my window. I saw her face. If I don't
say it, it's like — it's like I filmed it for nothing."
Tom put the pan down. He knelt — actually knelt, on the kitchen tile — so
he was looking up at his twelve-year-old daughter.
64
"You don't have to do this to protect me."
"I'm not doing it to protect you." She said it simply, the way she said
everything true. "I'm doing it because I was there."
Rachel, when Tom called her, was quiet for a long moment. "She's twelve.
The judge will allow it, but Porter will go after her — gently, because he has
to, but he'll try to rattle her. Are you sure?"
"No," Tom said. "But she's sure. And I've learned not to argue with her when
she's sure. She gets it from her mother."
"Smart woman, your ex-wife."
"Terrifying woman. In the best way."
They prepped Chloe the way they'd prepped Tom: tell the truth, keep it
boring, don't perform. Dev showed her the fifth angle on the big monitor, and
Chloe watched herself filming — watched her own twelve-year-old hands
holding steady — and said, "I look calm."
"You were calm," Tom said.
"I wasn't. I was counting. One-Mississippi, two-Mississippi. Mom taught me
that for thunderstorms." She looked at him. "It works for other things too."
The first day of trial arrived on a Tuesday in October, with the particular flat
gray light that made the courthouse look like a photograph of itself. Tom
wore the suit he'd bought for his divorce hearing — dark, forgettable, the suit
of a man who wanted the jury to look at the evidence instead of him. Chloe
wore a navy dress and her mother's bracelet, and she held Tom's hand in the
elevator, and neither of them mentioned it.
The courtroom filled slowly: reporters in the back row, Oakmont residents
scattered through the gallery like a seating chart of the schism — Gary
65
Lindqvist near the front on one side, Margaret Ellison on the other, the
garden committee women clustered together with tissues they wouldn't need
until later.
Diane Holloway sat at the defense table in a navy suit, hair pulled back
severe and smooth, no folder, no clipboard, nothing to hold. Tom had seen
her a hundred times across the neighborhood — at meetings, in her golf cart,
measuring someone's hedges with a yardstick — and he'd never seen her
empty-handed. It was the most honest he'd ever seen her look.
Paul Holloway sat two rows behind her, alone. He didn't look at Diane. He
looked at the floor, the way a man looks at something he's already decided to
sell.
The prosecutor — ADA David Kim, a compact man with a voice that carried
without rising — stood for his opening statement. He didn't pace. He stood
still, hands flat on the lectern, and looked at the jury like they were the only
people in the room.
"Ladies and gentlemen," he said, "this case is about what four cameras saw,
what a twelve-year-old saw, and what a woman in a swimsuit hoped no one