embezzlement: guilty, guilty, guilty.
Diane Holloway sat perfectly still through all of it, the way she had sat
through the video, and when the last "guilty" was read, something in her face
finally gave way — not tears, not yet, but the collapse of the architecture
underneath, the president's posture folding into an ordinary woman's
shoulders. Grant Porter put a hand on her arm, the practiced gesture of a
lawyer steadying a client, and she flinched away from it — the first
uncontrolled movement anyone had seen from her in four days of trial.
In the row behind the prosecution table, Chloe's hand found Tom's, and he
held it the way he'd held it when she was four and the pool was deep. Rachel
Simmons exhaled for what seemed like the first time in a week. Detective
Marsh, by the door, nodded once — not triumph, just the quiet confirmation
of a job finished properly. In the back rows, the Oakmont Estates neighbors
sat in a silence that wasn't celebration either; several of them had voted for
Diane Holloway twice, had let her run their meetings and spend their money,
and the verdicts landed on them too, as a question they would be asking
themselves for a long time: how had they not seen it, or had they seen it and
looked away because the lawns looked good?
Diane was remanded pending sentencing. As the deputies led her out, she
passed within three feet of the Beckett row, and Chloe — twelve years old,
who had filmed a woman climbing a fence and then testified about it to a
room full of strangers — looked up and met her eyes. Diane looked away
first.
Sentencing day came three weeks later, under a flat gray sky.
The courtroom was fuller this time — neighbors from Oakmont Estates filled
the back rows, the board members who had voted Diane out sitting together
86
near the aisle, Detective Marsh in uniform by the door. A local reporter sat in
the corner with a notebook, the only press Judge Morrison had allowed.
Diane wore gray, a color Tom had never seen on her; she had always dressed
like the room belonged to her, and gray was the color of rooms that belonged
to someone else. Paul Holloway's seat was empty again. Tom found himself
wondering, against his better judgment, what it did to a person to be
sentenced with no one in your row — and then he remembered Chloe
checking under the towel, and the wondering stopped.
Judge Morrison invited victim statements first. Tom stood, and he was brief,
because Rachel Simmons had told him juries remembered restraint and
judges did too.
"Your Honor," he said, "I don't hate Mrs. Holloway. I don't want her
destroyed. I want her to understand what she tried to take from my daughter
— not the pool, not the house. The feeling that home is safe. You can't buy
that back. You can't install it like a camera." He paused. "I asked for
restitution for the tox screen and the exterminator and the locks I changed.
I'm not asking for revenge. I'm asking for the record to show that what
happened in my backyard mattered."
Then Chloe stood, and the courtroom went quiet in a different way. She had
written her statement by hand, and she read it without looking up until the
end.
"After that Saturday, I didn't swim for a month," she read. "Every time I
looked at the pool I thought about the towel. My dad got the water tested and
showed me the results and I still couldn't get in. I take pictures of everything
because Dad says documentation matters, but I stopped taking pictures of the
pool. I didn't want to remember it." She turned the page. "I'm swimming
again now. But I check under the towel first. Every time. I'm twelve, and I
87
check under the towel before I sit by my own pool. That's what she gave me,
and I want the court to know it wasn't free."
She folded the paper, looked at the judge, and sat down. Tom put his arm
around her shoulders and didn't let go.
Diane's allocution came last. She stood, smoothed her skirt, and for a
moment the old command surfaced — the woman who had run meetings
with a gavel of her own. Then it broke, all at once, like ice on a pond.
"I told myself I was protecting the neighborhood," she said, and her voice
was raw. "That's what I said at every meeting, and I started to believe my
own minutes. Tom asked questions and I heard threats. The cameras — I felt
watched, and instead of asking myself why being watched frightened me, I
decided he was the problem." She looked toward the Becketts, then away,
unable to hold it. "I am not asking for forgiveness. I know what the video
shows. I know what I carried over that fence. I did it, and I am —" She
stopped, pressed her fingers to her mouth, and finished quietly: "I am sorry
for what I put that child through. That is the part I can't — I can't make that
one make sense."
Judge Morrison was silent for a long moment. Then she spoke, and her voice
filled the room the way a gavel does before it falls.
"Mrs. Holloway, this court has seen defendants who acted in rage, in panic,
in desperation. You acted in calculation. You climbed a locked fence in a
swimsuit with a syringe you purchased two days earlier, you placed it where
a child swims, and you intended for the police to find it and destroy a man's
life — because he asked where the money went." She leaned forward. "You
treated your neighbors as subjects. This community is not your kingdom."
The sentence: eighteen months in state prison, twelve suspended — six to
88
serve. Three years of supervised probation. Full restitution of the embezzled
funds, plus Tom Beckett's costs. Two hundred hours of community service.
And a permanent bar from serving on any homeowners' association board in
the state.