Garrett had overstated the status of the relationship when he implied that his company was already a strategic partner whose business the airline could not afford to lose.
The commercial team’s records were unambiguous.
Coleman Meridian was a prospective customer.
It was not an existing account entitled to special treatment.
That distinction mattered, but Margaret did not want the investigation to rely on it too heavily.
Even if Garrett had been an important customer, the conduct question would have remained the same.
The investigation was not supposed to establish that Garrett deserved consequences because his company was less important than he claimed.
It was supposed to establish that a passenger’s commercial influence did not determine whether misconduct occurred.
The team then examined Garrett’s messages.
His first message, sent shortly after the flight, described a mishandled passenger situation. It suggested that a Skylark executive had become involved in an unnecessary confrontation and that the airline should consider the impact on a potential commercial relationship.
The message did not mention that Garrett had deliberately poured champagne onto Brianna’s laptop.
His second message emphasized the importance of maintaining strong relationships with major business customers. It suggested that the airline should handle the matter discreetly and avoid allowing a minor customer-service issue to interfere with commercial discussions.
The investigators did not treat either email as proof of Garrett’s motive when he first lifted the glass.
They could not know everything he had been thinking at that moment.
However, the messages were relevant to the way he had attempted to influence the response afterward.
He had framed the incident as a service failure while omitting the conduct that had prompted the report.
He had also invoked the potential value of his company’s business before the airline had completed its review.
Margaret summarized the distinction in her notes.
The messages do not independently establish the original motive. They do establish an attempt to influence the subsequent handling of the incident.
That distinction would become important during the interview.
Garrett arrived at Skylark headquarters three days later wearing a tailored charcoal suit and carrying a leather folder filled with printed emails.
He was accompanied by his attorney.
He greeted the receptionist with the same confidence he displayed in boardrooms, then entered the interview room as though he expected to negotiate the terms of the conversation.
Margaret stood to greet him.
“Mr. Coleman. Thank you for coming.”
“Of course,” Garrett replied. “I assume we can resolve this quickly.”
Margaret indicated the chair opposite her.
“We will proceed as efficiently as the facts allow.”
His attorney sat beside him.
A second investigator joined Margaret at the table, and a note-taker sat slightly behind them. Everyone introduced themselves and explained their role.
Margaret then outlined the purpose of the meeting.
“We are conducting a fact-finding review of the incident aboard Flight 271. We have collected the crew’s report, witness accounts, and relevant communications. We would like your account of what happened and your response to several specific questions.”
Garrett opened his folder.
“Before we begin, I want to make clear that I have always had a professional relationship with Skylark. My company was considering a substantial commercial arrangement. We have invested considerable time in those discussions.”
“Thank you,” Margaret said. “We have reviewed the commercial records.”
“Then you understand the context.”
“We understand the status of the proposed arrangement.”
Garrett paused.
He had expected a more enthusiastic acknowledgment of his company’s importance.
Instead, Margaret moved to the first question.
“Mr. Coleman, please describe what happened from your perspective.”
Garrett leaned back.
“I was seated beside Ms. Brooks. She was working on her laptop and appeared unwilling to engage in conversation. I made a lighthearted comment. There was a spill, and the situation became more serious than it needed to be.”
“Did you deliberately pour champagne onto Ms. Brooks and her laptop?”
Garrett shifted in his seat.
“I didn't intend for the laptop to be damaged.”
“That wasn't my question.”
“I was making a joke.”
“Did you intentionally tilt your glass toward her?”
He hesitated.
“I was trying to get her attention.”
“Did you intend for the champagne to spill onto her?”
Garrett looked toward his attorney.
His attorney leaned slightly toward him.
“Answer the question directly.”
Garrett exhaled.
“I intended to make a point. I didn't expect it to become such a major incident.”
Margaret wrote down his answer.
“What point were you trying to make?”
Garrett folded his hands.
“She was acting as though she was more important than everyone else. She was working on her laptop, ignoring people, and taking up space in the cabin.”
“Did she prevent you from using your seat?”
“No.”
“Did she interfere with your belongings?”
“No.”
“Did she violate a cabin rule?”
“I don't know.”
“Did she insult you?”
Garrett hesitated.
“She was dismissive.”
“What did she say that you considered dismissive?”
“She said she preferred to finish her work before landing.”
Margaret waited.
Garrett’s expression grew defensive.
“I felt she was trying to make me look insignificant.”
“Did she say that?”
“No.”
“Did she mention your company?”
“No.”
“Did she ask you to stop speaking?”
“No.”
Margaret closed her notebook for a moment.
“Mr. Coleman, the purpose of this interview is to establish what happened. We are not asking whether you liked Ms. Brooks’s demeanor. We are asking whether your actions were deliberate and whether they violated the standards governing passenger conduct aboard Skylark Airlines.”
Garrett looked away.
“I understand.”
“Do you?”
He said nothing.
Margaret reopened the notebook.
“You have described the incident as a joke. Please explain what made it humorous.”