Garrett gave a short, irritated laugh.
“I wasn't trying to injure her. I wanted to make a point about how she was behaving.”
“What was the joke?”
“The spill.”
“What was funny about pouring champagne onto another passenger’s clothing and computer?”
“I didn't think it would cause that much damage.”
“That explains what you expected to happen. It does not explain what was humorous about the act.”
Garrett shifted again.
“I suppose it wasn't funny afterward.”
“Was it funny before?”
His attorney intervened.
“My client has answered questions about his intention. We do not believe repeatedly asking him to characterize the event differently will produce useful information.”
Margaret remained calm.
“We are asking him to explain his own description. If he considers the action a joke, we need to understand what he means by that.”
Garrett glanced at his attorney, then back at Margaret.
“I wanted to embarrass her a little. She seemed to think she was too important to talk to me.”
“Did you believe embarrassing her was an appropriate response?”
“I thought it would be a harmless joke.”
“Did you consider asking her why she did not want to talk?”
Garrett did not answer immediately.
“I suppose I could have.”
“Did you consider leaving her alone?”
“Yes.”
“Why didn't you?”
His jaw tightened.
“Because I was annoyed.”
Margaret wrote down the answer.
It was the clearest explanation he had offered so far.
Not a misunderstanding.
Not an accidental spill.
Not a joke that had somehow escaped his control.
He had been annoyed, and he had chosen to humiliate another passenger.
The interview continued.
Margaret asked about the moments immediately after the champagne spilled. Garrett confirmed that he had made the comment about buying a first-class seat. He insisted that the remark had been part of the joke.
“Did you know whether Ms. Brooks had purchased her own ticket?” Margaret asked.
“No.”
“Did you know whether she had any right to occupy Seat 3A?”
“Obviously, she was seated there.”
“Then why did you tell her to buy her own first-class seat?”
Garrett looked uncomfortable.
“I was being sarcastic.”
“Were you suggesting that she did not belong in first class?”
“I was making a point about her attitude.”
“Did you believe her attitude justified damaging her property?”
“No.”
“Did you believe it justified pouring champagne onto her?”
Garrett paused.
“No.”
Margaret let the silence remain.
The answer had finally separated his irritation from his conduct.
He could believe Brianna had been distant. He could dislike her response. He could feel insulted by a conversation that had not gone the way he wanted.
None of those feelings gave him permission to act as he had.
Margaret moved to the next section.
“After the incident, you contacted people associated with Skylark’s commercial department. Is that correct?”
“Yes.”
“What was the purpose of those messages?”
“To request professional treatment.”
“What did you mean by professional treatment?”
“I expected the company to deal with the matter fairly.”
“Did you disclose in your first message that you had deliberately poured champagne onto Ms. Brooks?”
Garrett hesitated.
“I didn't provide every detail.”
“Why not?”
“I was describing the situation from my perspective.”
“Did you believe the omitted detail was relevant?”
“I didn't think it needed to be the focus.”
“Why not?”
“Because the important issue was how the airline handled the confrontation.”
Margaret looked at him.
“The crew reported that you poured champagne onto another passenger. You have now acknowledged that you did so intentionally. Why would the crew’s response be the only important issue?”
Garrett’s face reddened.
“I never said it was the only important issue.”
“You described the event as a mishandled passenger situation without mentioning your own conduct. Is that accurate?”
He looked at his attorney.
The attorney did not intervene.
“Yes,” Garrett said finally.
“Did you refer to your company’s potential commercial relationship with Skylark in those messages?”
“Yes.”
“Why?”
“Because I believed it was relevant to how the matter should be handled.”
“Did you believe your company’s potential business entitled you to a different response under the passenger-conduct policy?”
“No.”
“Did you believe that invoking the potential relationship might influence the airline’s response?”
Garrett hesitated.
“I thought they should consider the broader relationship.”
Margaret made a note.
“Thank you.”
The interview continued for nearly another hour.
Garrett provided his account of the conversation, his recollection of the crew’s response, and his understanding of the proposed commercial arrangement. He repeatedly returned to the idea that the situation had been exaggerated.
But every time Margaret asked him to identify a specific action by Brianna that justified his behavior, his explanation weakened.
Brianna had not prevented him from using his seat.
She had not interfered with his belongings.
She had not insulted him.
She had simply chosen to continue working.
Garrett had interpreted that choice as a challenge to his importance.
Then he had responded by making her feel small.
When the interview ended, Margaret explained that the investigation team would review the evidence and submit its findings to the designated decision-makers. No final disciplinary determination had been made.
Garrett seemed dissatisfied.
“After all this, you're still refusing to tell me what will happen?”
“We are following the review process.”
“You know who I am.”
“Yes,” Margaret replied. “We have verified your identity.”
The answer was so literal that Garrett’s attorney looked down to hide a brief smile.
Garrett stood.
“This is not over.”
Margaret remained seated.
“The review will proceed according to policy.”
He left the room furious.