His Wife Told His Daughter She Was “Too Old” to Live at Home — Then He Applied the Same Rule to Her Own Children

Chapter 5

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"Because she's fine," Denise said, and her voice rose a little, the first crack in her composure. "She's always been fine. She doesn't need us the way they do. Jordan and Brianna are my kids, Marcus. They're my responsibility. I have to look out for them."

Marcus nodded slowly. He had expected this, in some way, even before she said it. He had heard the words forming in her voice before they came out of her mouth. "And Maya is my daughter," he said. "She is my responsibility. She is my child, just like they are yours. The difference is that I don't ask you to choose between them. I never have."

Denise stood up from the table, pushing her chair back with a scrape. "That's not fair," she said. "You're making it sound like I don't care about Maya. I do care about her. I just think she's ready. She's strong. She can handle it. Jordan and Brianna aren't ready yet. They need more time. That's all I'm saying."

"Then give Maya the same time," Marcus said. He stayed seated. He did not stand to meet her. He kept his hands on the table and his voice steady. "If the rule is that grown children need to leave, then the rule has to be the same for everyone. If Maya has to leave because she's twenty-two and grown, then Jordan has to leave because he's twenty-six and grown, and Brianna has to leave because she's twenty-four and grown. You can't have one rule for my daughter and a different rule for yours."

Denise stared at him. "You can't be serious," she said. "Jordan has nowhere to go. Brianna has no income. You can't just throw them out. They would have nothing."

"And Maya has somewhere to go?" Marcus asked. "She has no apartment waiting. She has no savings for a deposit and first month's rent and furniture, not on what she makes at the clinic while she's paying for school. You told her to be gone by dinner tonight. Where was she supposed to go? A friend's couch? Her car?"

Denise opened her mouth, and then closed it. She sat back down, slowly, and picked up her glass of iced tea with both hands, as if she needed something to hold. For the first time since Marcus had walked into the room, she looked uncertain. Not angry, not defensive, but uncertain, the way a person looks when a plan they were sure about suddenly stops making sense to them.

"I didn't think about it like that," she said, quietly.

"Think about it now," Marcus said.

Before she could answer, there was a sound from the doorway. Marcus turned, and Denise turned, and they both saw Maya standing there in the hall, pulling her suitcase behind her. The wheels caught on the edge of the rug. Her eyes were swollen from crying, and her ponytail had come loose completely now, her long dark hair falling around her shoulders. She was still wearing the grey hoodie and black pants. She had heard the whole conversation. Marcus could tell from her face. She had heard Denise say that Jordan and Brianna were her kids. She had heard him say that Maya was his daughter. She had heard the part about the rule being the same for everyone.

She stopped in the doorway and looked at Denise, and then at Marcus, and she did not say anything for a moment. The house was very quiet. The refrigerator hummed. The clock on the wall ticked. Denise looked at Maya, and then at Marcus, and for the first time since he had known her, Denise looked truly afraid. Not afraid of him. Afraid of what she had done, and what it might cost her, and what it said about the family she had thought she was building.

Maya set the handle of the suitcase down carefully, so it did not bang against the floor. She stood up straight, and when she spoke, her voice was shaky but clear, and it was her own voice, not the small, apologetic one she had used upstairs.

"I heard what you said, Denise," she said. "About me being grown and being able to look after myself. You're right that I'm grown. I am. I work full-time. I pay my phone and I buy groceries and I help with the bills. I'm taking classes so I can become a nurse. I'm not asking anyone to take care of me. But I am asking to be treated the same as everyone else in this house. If the rule is that grown-ups have to leave, then fine, I'll leave. But I won't be the only one who has to go because I'm the easy one to send away. I'm not leaving just because it's convenient for you to have me gone and hard for you to say the same thing to your own kids."

News in the same category

His Wife Told His Daughter She Was “Too Old” to Live at Home — Then He Applied the Same Rule to Her Own Children

45 Part