HOA Cut My Ranch Lock for an Inspection—Then Panicked When They Realized Who I Was

Chapter 17

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Nora filed the civil action the following week, in the county court, and I read it over coffee at her office before she filed it, the way I had read everything else. The petition asked the court for two things, and only two things. First, a declaration that the ranch at 6847 Ridgeway Ranch Road was not subject to the Stone Creek Estates Homeowners Association, its declaration, its fines, or its assessments. Second, expungement of the lien — its removal from the record, as if it had never been a valid claim at all. It attached the deed, the plat, the survey, the easement language, the letters, the minutes Arthur had shared, the trespass report, and the dispute I had filed with the recorder. It was, in effect, the binder, turned into a court filing.

Nora walked me through the petition page by page, and I asked her two questions, both of them plain. I asked whether the declaration language she quoted was the same language Rebecca had cited in her fine notices, and she said it was, and that the petition quoted it in full so the court could see what it actually said about member lots. I asked whether the expungement request covered the costs the lien claimed as well as the $4,500, and she said it did, because the costs rested on the same claim, and if the claim failed, the costs failed with it. I signed where she showed me, and she made a copy for me before she left for the courthouse, and I carried that copy home like I had carried every other copy home, and put it where it belonged.

I filed my copy of the petition in the binder under the LIEN tab, behind the dispute and behind the certified copy of the lien itself, so that the tab now told the whole story in order: the assessment, the denial, the lien, and the action asking a court to say what the paper had said all along. I added a line to the timeline, with the case number Nora had given me, and I wrote it in the same hand I had used for every other line, because the timeline was still the timeline, and the lien had not changed the way I kept it.

That evening I sat on the porch with coffee and read the petition once more, not because I needed to, but because I wanted to be sure I understood what I had asked a court to do. I had asked it to read the paper and say what the paper said. That was all. I was not surprised that the lien had been filed, and I was not surprised that the answer to it was a filing of my own. The paper war had moved from mailboxes to a courtroom, and the ranch was still the ranch, and the gate was still locked, and the record was still the record. I went inside when the light went, and I locked the door, and I slept.

Rebecca's letter to the residents of Stone Creek Estates did not come to me in the mail. It came to me through Arthur Hale, who brought a copy to the gate on a Sunday afternoon, folded once, with the Stone Creek letterhead at the top and Rebecca's signature at the bottom, and he handed it to me through the chain with an expression I had seen before, the expression of a man who had read something he did not agree with and wanted someone else to know it existed.

The letter called the ranch a blight on the community. It said the fencing was deteriorating, the outbuildings were unsightly, and the visible land conditions were dragging down the appearance of the streets that bordered the property. It said the association had tried, repeatedly, to bring the property into compliance, and that the owner had refused every reasonable request, and that the residents deserved to know why their neighborhood looked the way it did at its edge. It did not mention that I was not a member. It did not mention the plat, or the survey, or the easement, or the dispute on the record. It mentioned the ranch as if it were a lot in the subdivision that had simply decided not to cooperate.

News in the same category

HOA Cut My Ranch Lock for an Inspection—Then Panicked When They Realized Who I Was

45 Part