HOA Cut My Ranch Lock for an Inspection—Then Panicked When They Realized Who I Was

Chapter 6

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The second letter arrived a week later, in the same kind of envelope, stamped with the same association name, addressed the same way. I knew what it was before I opened it, because there are only so many reasons for a second letter to follow a refusal, and none of them are good.

Inside, the language was firmer. The association now assessed "noncompliance" fines of $150 per day for fencing and outbuildings, beginning on a date it had chosen and continuing until the conditions were corrected. It cited sections of the Stone Creek Estates declaration, printed as numbers and subsections, as if numbers alone made a claim true. It did not enclose the declaration. It did not explain how a parcel outside the association had become subject to it. It simply stated the fines and the total that would follow if I did not comply.

I read the letter twice, the same way I had read the first one. Then I did what I should have done the first time the declaration was mentioned at my gate: I went to the public record myself and read the sections the letter cited. I did not rely on the association's summary. I did not rely on my memory of the closing binder, either. I pulled the recorded declaration and read the cited language in full, in context, with the definitions section open beside it.

The sections applied, on their face, to member lots. The language said so, plainly, in the definitions and again in the enforcement provisions. Member lots were lots within the subdivision, conveyed subject to the declaration, and listed on the plat. My ranch was none of those things. It was an older agricultural parcel, separately described, separately conveyed, and never made subject to the declaration by any document I had found or the county had recorded. The fines, as written, were fines against someone else's property, mailed to my address.

I logged the letter, dated it in pencil, and filed it in the binder behind the certified letter and the gate note. I wrote a short entry beside it: date received, amount claimed, sections cited, and my own note that the sections governed member lots only. Then I went outside, because paper should not be the whole day, and the ranch still needed walking.

I walked the fence line to the section that leaned worst, near the dry creek bed, and I looked at the post the association had presumably meant when it wrote the word "fencing." The post was old, and it leaned, and it was mine. The barn board that had come loose in the last wind was mine too. I would fix both of them, on my own schedule, because a ranch needs keeping, not because a letter had told me to. There was a difference, and the difference was the whole point.

That evening, I stood at the barn and looked at the roof that needed replacing, and at the pasture beyond it, and I felt steady rather than angry. Anger would have been easy, and useless. The binder was getting thicker, and that was fine. A thicker binder was a clearer record. The fines could accrue on paper for as long as the association wanted to write them. Paper, I had learned long ago, is patient, and so was I.

I also made a habit that week of checking the mailbox at the same time each day and logging whatever arrived before I opened anything else, so that no letter could later be said to have arrived on a different day than it did. I kept the envelopes, not just the letters, because a postmark is a date too. The envelopes went into a folder at the back of the binder, in order, with the fines letters in front of them. It was unglamorous work, the kind nobody writes about, but it was the work that would matter if anyone ever had to reconstruct the sequence. A dispute like this is won or lost on sequence: what was sent, when it was sent, what was answered, and what was never answered at all. I intended my sequence to be complete.

Before dark, I walked the whole fence line once, slowly, and I counted the sections that still leaned. There were more than I would have liked, and fewer than there had been when I bought the place. Each one was a job for a future morning, not a violation to be confessed. I came back to the house as the light failed, and the ranch settled around me the way it always did, indifferent to the mail and entirely mine.

News in the same category

HOA Cut My Ranch Lock for an Inspection—Then Panicked When They Realized Who I Was

45 Part