The reviewer also found that the engineering firm had issued a scope warning before the contractor was engaged. The warning stated that the project could not proceed across the Miller parcel without a recorded access agreement and that the drainage easement was insufficient. The warning had been sent to Hoa and copied to the project coordinator. It had not been included in the board packet.
Mark read the report at the clubhouse with Linda and Sheila. He was disappointed but not surprised. The documents showed a pattern: each time a restriction threatened to delay the runway, the project file became less complete rather than more complete. Important information had been summarized, withheld, or described as a detail for later review.
The report did not accuse Hoa of a crime. It recommended that the board refer the matter to counsel and the insurer, recover any unearned payments, and consider whether the president had violated the association's conflict-of-interest and spending policies.
The board scheduled a special meeting and invited Hoa to respond. She arrived with her own copy of the report and a written statement. She said the project had been driven by enthusiasm, not personal gain. She acknowledged that the full easement should have been shown to the board earlier and that the revised alignment should have received a separate vote. She denied that the success fee had influenced her decisions.
Mark asked whether she would return the Westline payment.
Hoa said the company had performed coordination work.
“Then show the deliverables,” he said.
She referred to the presentation materials and the revised plan. Mark replied that the association had already paid the engineering firm for the plan, and that the Westline invoice described access coordination that had not produced an access right.
Richard advised the board to avoid making a final finding about intent until the reviewer completed the audit. He said the board could still decide whether Hoa's conduct undermined its confidence in her ability to serve as president.
Sheila moved for a vote of no confidence and requested that Hoa voluntarily resign. Linda seconded the motion. Mark said he would support it. The remaining directors discussed the matter in detail. One member said Hoa had devoted years to the association and deserved a chance to correct the mistakes. Another said the board could not protect a president at the expense of the residents and the neighboring farm.
Hoa spoke again. She described the hours she had spent on neighborhood projects, the improvements she had overseen, and the fact that no plane had ever taken off from the contested strip. She asked the board to remember what she had accomplished before judging her by one project.
Linda replied that the problem was not one project. It was the decision to hide information that might have changed the board's vote.
The vote was four to one in favor of no confidence. The board did not have the votes to remove Hoa under the association's bylaws, but it formally requested her resignation and transferred all remaining project authority to a committee.
Hoa refused to resign that evening. She said she would finish the term and allow the membership to decide.
When the meeting ended, she returned to her office to find the scale model airplane still sitting on the shelf. She picked it up and turned it over in her hands. The small plastic wheels were clean. The model had never touched the field.
She placed it back on the shelf, but this time she did not straighten its wings.
The family farm entered winter with the runway still incomplete and the legal dispute unresolved. A cold rain turned the disturbed soil near the drainage ditch into a slick patch of mud. Ethan and Ryan walked the boundary after breakfast and found that the temporary berm had begun to channel water toward the north pasture. It was not a disaster, but it was a warning that the site needed restoration before spring.
They sent photographs to Grace Wilcox and Mary Caldwell. The county engineer scheduled another inspection and asked the association to provide a corrective plan. The site supervisor proposed removing the berm and restoring the ditch to its prior grade. Grace said the work had to be reviewed and coordinated with the Millers so that it did not create further disturbance.
Wade Larkin, the first contractor, called Ethan after hearing about the problem. He said he had declined the runway job because the access was not documented, but he was willing to bid on a limited restoration project if the county approved the scope and the landowners agreed. Ethan appreciated the offer. He did not trust contractors automatically, but Wade had shown that he understood the difference between a work order and a right to enter.