Judge Porter asked about the association itself, as distinct from Karen. Lindgren conceded a point there, and I appreciated his honesty even as it stung: some claims against the association as an entity, to the extent they rested only on Karen's unauthorized act rather than on any board policy, would need to be narrowed. He did not concede the core. Trespass and destruction, he argued, survived against Karen personally, and the association remained in the case for the declaratory relief I sought: the voiding of notices and a clear rule on future entry.
Her ruling, delivered two weeks later in writing, denied the motion in part. The case would proceed on trespass and destruction of property against Karen, and on the request for declaratory relief. Certain broader claims against the association were dismissed, as Lindgren had anticipated. The ruling did not decide who was right in the end. It decided something narrower and, for me, more important: that a claim of immunity could not end the case before the facts were heard.
I read the order at Lindgren's office, slowly, because legal language rewards slowness. "Denied in part," he said, tapping the phrase. "That means we go forward. Discovery continues. Depositions continue. The work order will be examined under oath, not just argued about in a motion."
Outside, the afternoon was ordinary. Cars passed. A neighbor walked a dog. The case had survived its first attempt to make it disappear, and the record, which had carried me this far, would now be tested in the open.
Judge Porter, in her written order, was careful to say what she had not decided. She had not decided whether Karen believed she had authority, or whether the association's documents gave a president any discretion at all in other circumstances. She had decided only that those questions could not be answered by dismissing the case at its threshold, when the central fact — the absence of a vote — was itself in dispute and supported by documents. That distinction stayed with me. The ruling did not declare me right. It declared the facts relevant, and the record admissible, and the questions worth asking under oath. For a case built on paper, that was the only opening it needed.
Discovery, Lindgren had warned me, would be slow and unglamorous, and he was right. There were no courtroom speeches. There were boxes, and then there were more boxes, and then there were emails printed in stacks that smelled faintly of warm paper. But inside that dullness, the case changed shape, because documents, unlike people, cannot revise their memories.
The first set of emails was between Karen and the association's management company. In one, dated weeks before the cutting, Karen asked how to word a compliance action so that a crew would accept it without asking for a board resolution. The reply, from a property manager, was cautious: it suggested she obtain board approval first. There was no reply from Karen to that suggestion in the file. The next email in the chain was her message to Cedar Tree Works, attaching the work order.
The second find was the tag purchase. Lindgren obtained the receipt from an office supply store, dated three weeks before the cutting, for a pack of yellow plastic tags and a marker. The tags in the photographs from my yard matched the receipt's description, and Karen's own handwriting, in black marker, matched the lettering on the tags tied to the stumps. She had bought them herself. She had written HOA COMPLIANCE ACTION herself. She had tied them herself, or directed that they be tied, to make a private decision look like a public action.
The third find was the work order draft on Karen's computer. The forensic copy showed a file created the day before the cutting, edited twice that evening, and printed once, early the next morning. There were no earlier drafts. There was no version sent to Robert Hale or Joan Meyer for review. There was no email attaching it to any board member. The metadata told the same story as the paper itself: one author, one evening, one signature.
The fourth find was an absence, and absences, Lindgren said, can be evidence too. The board minutes for the months around the cutting contained no mention of my trees, no motion for removal, no vote of any kind. Joan Meyer's minutes were careful and complete on other subjects: budgets, pool repairs, a dispute about a fence on another street. On my trees, there was silence. When Lindgren asked the association to produce any missing minutes, the answer came back that none existed. You cannot produce a vote that never happened, and you cannot backdate a silence.