"I'd ask for the vote," Jesse said. "I'd ask to see it written down, with more than one name on it. And if I couldn't see it, I wouldn't start the saw."
When the deposition ended, Jesse stood and shook my hand. His grip was firm, and his eyes were tired. He was not a villain in this story. He was a man who had asked the right question once, had accepted the wrong answer, and was now answering for it under oath, truthfully, without embellishment. His testimony did not make Karen's work order stronger. It showed exactly how it had worked: one signature, one title, and a hesitant man who had wanted to believe both.
Lindgren asked Jesse about the tags a second time, because the tags had done work long after the crew left. Jesse said he understood that now. A tag left on a stump tells anyone who walks past that an authority has acted, and it discourages questions. He said he had tied them because Karen had handed them to him and told him it was standard practice, and because, in the hurry of the morning, standard practice had sounded like a sufficient reason. He wished, he said, that he had asked what standard, and whose practice, and where it was written down. Those were the questions he had not known to ask at five in the morning, and the questions he would ask for the rest of his working life.
Jesse also told Lindgren, after the formal questions ended, that he had changed how he accepted homeowners association work. He now asked for a board resolution in writing before any crew left the yard, and he had told two other crew leads to do the same. It was a small change, he said, made too late for my trees, but he hoped it would spare the next homeowner a morning like mine.
Danny O'Neil's deposition was shorter, and in some ways harder to hear, because Danny had held the saw. He arrived in work boots and a jacket, sat down carefully, and answered Lindgren's questions in the plain language of a man describing a job he wished he had refused.
He remembered the morning by its pace. Karen had wanted the work done quickly, before the street woke up. He remembered her pointing at the trees, one by one, and Jesse asking his question at the fence. He remembered Karen's answer, though he had heard it from a few feet away: already approved, president, requirements. He had not asked a question himself. He had assumed Jesse had settled it.
"The saw was already out of the truck," he said. "When the saw is out, the job feels started."
Lindgren asked him to describe the cutting, and Danny did, without pride and without hiding. He described the largest maple first, the cut almost through, the tree coming down across the grass. He described the dogwood, and one magnolia the same way. He described the second maple and the second magnolia chopped near their bases. He described the serviceberry last, dragged toward the driveway because it was smaller and easier to move, leaving the long brown trail I had found with my coffee in my hand.
"Did you notice the tags?" Lindgren asked.
"Yes," Danny said. "Yellow tags. Karen had them in her pocket, I think. Or in her folder. Jesse tied some of them. They said HOA compliance something. I didn't read them close. I figured if there were tags, there was paperwork somewhere."
"Was there paperwork somewhere, that you saw?"
"Just the one page," Danny said. "The work order. I saw it in Karen's hand, but I didn't read it. I was setting up the saw."
Alden asked whether Danny had known the trees were on private property. Danny said he had known they were inside a fence, and that he had assumed the association had the right to enter because the president was standing there telling him so. He said he had cut trees for associations before, and that those jobs had always come with a packet: a resolution, a notice to the homeowner, sometimes a second signature. This job had come with one page and a woman in a dark jacket.
"What did you think the morning after?" Lindgren asked.
"I thought about it all day," Danny said. "I kept thinking about the fence, and about Jesse's question. I wished I'd stopped when he asked it. A question like that is a reason to stop, not a reason to hurry."