Pete Sandoval came back to the farm track in April, on a Saturday, in his own truck rather than a company vehicle, and he stood at the boundary stone, where Samuel's coffee cup had stood in Solano's photograph, and asked whether he could walk the trench line with him. The trench had long been restored by then, the house line relaid under the emergency order, the ground reseeded, so that the walk was over grass, along a seam in the turf that only a man who had dug it could still read. Pete walked it slowly. He had come, he said, to give Samuel a copy of a letter, because he believed a man should hear a thing from the person it concerned and not from the county paper. The letter was from the county attorney's office, addressed to Pete's lawyer, and it stated, in the careful language of such letters, that after review of the file, including his statement and the statements of his driver, the office declined to bring any charge against Pete Sandoval in connection with the excavation, citing, as the ground of the declination, his stop-work decision and his call to the county from the site, made before any official was present and against his own commercial interest. A declination is not a verdict, and Pete, who had been listening to lawyers for a year, said so himself, with a grin that did not reach very far. It is a letter that says the office will not come. He had kept his licence.
His company had kept its contract with the county, though it had lost, by mutual agreement phrased as a business decision, its work for the association. He had come to say that he was sorry about the pipe. He said it standing on the seam of his own trench, in the plain words of a man who has rehearsed them in a truck cab. He had cut a man's water off in the man's own ground, on a print he had doubted, and the doubt, he said, should have stopped the bucket sooner than the valve arrows did. Samuel, who had thought about Pete a good deal in the year since the morning, and who had concluded that the second asking for a certified map was the hinge on which the whole history had turned, told him the truth as he recorded it. He said the statement Pete had given, and the call Pete had made, were in the state's file under Pete's own name, and that any person who read that file in the future would find the foreman who asked twice, stopped the job, and telephoned the county from the trench, and that a man's record, in Samuel's profession, was the sum of what he did when the print was wrong. They shook hands on the seam of the trench.
Pete drove away up the farm track at the pace Solano had set, the pace that respects the evidence, and Samuel put the copy of the declination letter in the file, in its chronological place, between the examiner's opinion and the insurer's letter, which arrived the following week.
The insurer's letter was addressed to the association, and a copy reached Samuel through Henry, in Henry's capacity as treasurer, in an envelope marked with the hours during which residents might inspect it, which was Henry's way of saying that it belonged to everyone. The association's insurer, having reviewed the matters set out in the state's file and the referral, stated its coverage position in five pages of the dense, qualified prose that insurers keep for the moments when they wish to be understood by lawyers and by no one else. The position, translated by Henry at the kitchen table for the benefit of the volunteers who had become, by then, a standing committee of the curious, was that the policy responded to some claims and not to others, that the matters arising from the easement document were, in the insurer's view, outside the cover for reasons the letter set out at length, and that the association should govern itself accordingly. It was not a ruling. It bound no court. It was a letter, from a company, about money, and Samuel filed it as such, noting only that in the year of paper, even the refusals now arrived in writing, addressed, dated, and inspectable during stated hours, which was a kind of progress that his father's generation would have recognised as civilisation and his own generation had learned to recognise as the beginning of it.