Patrick looked down. "The sales brochures were still in the closing packets. People kept talking about the road as if it were a public street. I thought the county would sort it out. I was wrong."
He explained that after the county rejected the discontinuance request, the board's attorney had recommended a private access agreement with Ruth Bell. The board had discussed it but never completed a vote. Then the attorney retired, the management company dissolved, and the issue faded into the background. Patrick had assumed that the county's rejection meant the route remained available as before. He had not understood that the county's decision merely kept the question open.
Mara listened without interrupting. Patrick's explanation was plausible, but it was also full of decisions made by people who had not lived in East Court and who were willing to let a technical uncertainty sit because resolving it would cost money. His signature had helped start the chain. His silence had allowed it to continue.
"I need you to give the board a written statement," she said. "Everything you remember, including the attorney's advice and the letter you say you never saw. We will disclose it to the county."
Patrick bristled. "You want me to admit I caused this."
"I want you to tell the truth. The county can decide what it means."
He looked toward the window. A group of children were crossing the clubhouse lawn on their way to the school bus. "I will look for my files," he said. "But do not turn this into a public hanging."
"Twenty-three families are already being asked to explain why their access is uncertain. I will not promise that your part stays private."
Patrick nodded once. He left without shaking her hand.
That afternoon, Mara met the remaining members of the old board at a diner near the courthouse. Two were elderly and hard of hearing; the third had moved to another state but joined by video. They remembered the 2006 request differently. One recalled a vote to ask for an updated traffic study. Another remembered a draft agreement that would have limited harvest traffic to daylight hours. None remembered a vote to remove residential access. They all agreed that the old attorney, Milton Kaye, had warned them that the lane was legally ambiguous and that the HOA should not assume it had control over the land. One former board member remembered a sentence from him: "You cannot solve a title problem with a gate." Mara wrote it down.
The diner conversation produced another name: Lydia Fen, the county's former subdivision clerk. Lydia had retired to a small town two counties away. The former board member said she had been the person who carried the original East Court plans between planning, public works, and the recorder's office. If anyone knew how the final agreement had disappeared, it might be her.
Mara called Elena. The county counsel said Lydia's personnel file was not public, but she could contact her through the retired employees' association. Elena also warned Mara that the county had received a letter from Northline asking it to issue a formal notice that the harvest corridor was private and not available for residential access. The company had argued that the old temporary waiver had expired and that the residents' reliance on the brochures could not burden the orchard. The county had not agreed, but it had not rejected the request either.
"They want us to fight over the lock instead of the missing road," Mara said.
"They want a clean answer that protects their title," Elena replied. "And the county wants to avoid admitting it allowed a subdivision to proceed without the required access. We have different reasons to be careful."
Mara asked whether the county would consider a negotiated emergency easement. Elena said it could, but the landowner would have to consent and the route would have to meet safety standards. The county could not force Ruth Bell to accept constant traffic because the developer had made a promise thirty years earlier. It could, however, investigate whether Northline or its predecessor remained responsible for the costs of a compliant connection.
Before hanging up, Elena mentioned something she had found in a separate public works ledger. In 1992, a temporary construction bond had been issued for the Mill Run crossing. It had been canceled the following year, but the ledger did not identify who received the refund. The amount was modest by modern road-building standards, but large enough to have funded a proper culvert and a substantial part of the bridge approach. The bond's cancellation was recorded as "work accepted," even though Thomas's affidavit said the crossing was incomplete.