The next problem was who would pay. Malcolm's cost estimate placed the reinforced crossing, lane widening, turnout, gate hardware, drainage work, and engineering supervision at a figure higher than the HOA could raise without a severe special assessment. The county drainage reserve could contribute to the work on the county-owned strip, but its budget was limited. Northline had offered one third of the construction cost, provided it received a release of historical claims. The old bond payment might support a claim against Wexler's estate or the consultant's insurer, but a recovery was uncertain and could take years.
The residents debated whether to accept Northline's offer. A group led by Lewis wanted the company to pay the whole amount because the developer had failed to build the road. Others believed a partial contribution was better than litigation. June asked for an independent cost review before any agreement was signed. Mara arranged a meeting with a civil engineer who had not worked for the county or Northline. He confirmed the estimate but found a way to reduce it: the county drainage reserve could carry the outlet channel, and a narrower concrete box crossing would support the required emergency vehicles without requiring the larger steel span. The design would preserve the old trees and avoid the packing shed. It would not support heavy commercial trucks, but the orchard's harvest equipment could use the reinforced lane under a separate loading limit.
The savings brought the project within reach if the parties shared the cost. The county would fund the drainage and survey work. Northline would contribute a negotiated amount as part of a settlement. The HOA would create a ten-year maintenance reserve financed by a modest annual assessment. The Bell family would grant the easement without selling the orchard strip, and the county would compensate them for the permanent burden on the land. The arrangement was not perfect for anyone. It was, however, more honest than the old promise and more durable than a temporary gate code.
Adrian Pike returned with a revised settlement proposal. Northline would contribute forty percent of the estimated construction cost, not one third, in exchange for a limited release of claims arising from the original development approval. The release would not protect the company from claims based on fraud, intentional concealment, or obligations that the county determined had survived the acquisition. Adrian said the company needed certainty before spending money on a road that would remain privately controlled. Mara asked whether the release would include the old bond guarantee and the withheld agreement. Adrian said it would cover the construction contribution and the company's role in the current settlement, but it could not erase the county's separate investigation.
Mara took the proposal to the residents. She did not recommend acceptance until they had seen the final easement. Some residents objected that forty percent was too little. Others argued that if Northline paid nothing, the HOA would have to carry the cost while the company kept the homes' sale revenue. June pointed out that the original developer had taken the bond money and that the modern company had found the assets valuable enough to buy. She wanted the county to pursue every available claim before signing a release.
Elena explained the risk. A lawsuit could take years, and the evidence was strong but not conclusive on successor liability. The company could argue that it had purchased selected assets without assuming Wexler's old obligations. The county might win, but residents would still be waiting for a safe crossing. The settlement would not absolve the past; it would fund a remedy in the present. The public integrity review could continue independently, and the county could preserve any claim it might later establish.
Mara asked the residents to vote on whether to authorize negotiations, not whether to accept a final agreement. The motion passed by a clear majority. She recorded the dissenting votes and attached the written objections to the minutes. One owner, a retired accountant named Vera Lott, told Mara privately that she had supported the motion because she did not want the next generation to inherit an endless lawsuit. She also warned Mara that the HOA could not let the new maintenance fund become another obscure account that no one understood. Mara agreed to publish a quarterly ledger and require two board signatures for any withdrawal above a specified amount.