Carter scanned the first page.
Then he turned to the second.
By the time he reached the summary of the arrest, his expression had hardened.
"Who reviewed this before it reached me?"
"The overnight shift commander."
"Has anyone examined the body-camera footage?"
"Not yet. The officer's initial report was submitted, but the video hasn't been reviewed by Internal Affairs."
Carter looked up.
"Why not?"
"The incident was initially classified as a routine detention."
The chief leaned back.
"A man was handcuffed at his own residence, transported to the station, and released without charges. How is that routine?"
His assistant said nothing.
Carter picked up his phone.
"Get me Lieutenant Harris. Then contact Internal Affairs and tell them I want an independent review initiated this morning. Preserve every recording associated with the incident."
"Yes, Chief."
"And find out whether any supervisor authorized the detention or directed the officer to continue holding him."
His assistant left.
Carter looked at the report again.
He had not yet watched the video. He did not know Jordan Ellis or his family. He had no reason to assume that the officer had acted improperly.
But he knew that an investigation could not begin with the assumption that the officer's report was correct.
It had to begin with the evidence.
At 7:15 a.m., his assistant returned with another message.
"The video is spreading rapidly online. Local news stations are asking for comment."
Carter rubbed his forehead.
"Of course they are."
"Would you like communications to issue a statement?"
"Not until we know what happened. Prepare a brief acknowledgment that the incident is under review. Do not defend the officer, and do not characterize the young man as a suspect unless we can substantiate that description."
His assistant nodded.
"And Chief?"
"Yes?"
"There's another issue."
Carter looked up.
"The attorney representing Mr. Ellis has sent a formal evidence-preservation notice. He is requesting dispatch recordings, body-camera footage, patrol-car video, station security footage, and communications relating to the complaint."
Carter was silent for several seconds.
"Who is the attorney?"
"Marcus Reed."
The chief recognized the name.
Reed had challenged the department before, and while Carter did not always agree with his arguments, he respected the lawyer's attention to detail.
"Send the notice to legal counsel immediately," Carter said. "And make sure nobody deletes, overwrites, or modifies any relevant records."
"Understood."
After his assistant left, Carter opened the department's incident-management system.
He entered Jordan Ellis's name.
The system returned the arrest record, the original complaint, and several associated entries.
One item caught his attention.
A dispatch note had been added shortly before the patrol car arrived at the Ellis residence.
The note was brief, but it referred to an earlier neighborhood complaint involving the same address.
Carter clicked on the entry.
The screen loaded slowly.
Then a name appeared.
Reporting party: Margaret Whitmore.
Carter stared at the screen.
He remembered Whitmore's name. She had contacted the department several times over the previous year, usually about alleged disturbances, suspicious vehicles, or people she claimed did not belong in the neighborhood.
Most of her complaints had been closed without action.
One, however, had resulted in a formal review after a resident alleged that an officer had treated a visitor unfairly.
Carter opened that record.
The incident was older, but a pattern was beginning to emerge.
Whitmore had complained about people entering or using properties in the neighborhood. In several cases, the people she described as suspicious had been residents, invited guests, or service workers.
The complaints were not proof of wrongdoing by Whitmore, and Carter was not prepared to draw conclusions about her motives.
But they were relevant.
He called Lieutenant Harris.
"Harris, I want to know everything you can tell me about yesterday's detention of Jordan Ellis."
"We're reviewing it now, Chief."
"Did you examine the body-camera footage?"
"Not yet."
"Then examine it. And I want the original dispatch audio preserved before anyone begins preparing summaries."
"Yes, Chief."
Carter paused.
"One more question. Did Officer Miller communicate with the reporting party before approaching Ellis?"
There was a silence on the line.
"I don't know, sir."
"Find out."
"Understood."
Carter ended the call and sat quietly for a moment.
He had inherited a department with problems that were not always visible in official statistics. Most officers did their jobs without incident. Many served their communities with patience and professionalism.
But the department had also developed habits that made certain failures difficult to detect.
Complaints were sometimes treated as facts before they were investigated.
Officers were sometimes trusted more readily than the people they detained.
Supervisors sometimes focused on whether paperwork had been completed instead of whether the underlying decision had been justified.
Those habits could turn a minor encounter into a serious injustice.
Carter had spent years promising to change them.
Now he had a chance to find out whether those promises meant anything.
At 8:03 a.m., he entered the conference room where Internal Affairs had begun assembling the available records.
A senior investigator named Patricia Cole stood beside a large monitor.
"We have the patrol-car footage, the body-camera file, and the dispatch log," she said. "The station's security recording is being retrieved."