Miller looked down at the table.
“He questioned why I needed it.”
“Is questioning an officer's request the same as refusing it?”
“I interpreted his response as noncompliance.”
“Did he physically resist you?”
“No.”
“Did he attempt to flee?”
“No.”
“Did he threaten to harm you?”
“No.”
Patricia placed the incident report beside the photograph.
“Your report says Mr. Ellis failed to provide a satisfactory explanation for his presence. You have now confirmed that he told you he lived at the residence. Why did you consider that explanation unsatisfactory?”
Miller's face reddened.
“He could have been lying.”
“Did you have evidence that he was lying?”
“Not at that point.”
“Did you have evidence that he had committed a crime?”
“I had a complaint.”
“A complaint is information. What did you independently observe that supported detention?”
Miller leaned back.
“I think we're going in circles.”
“We are trying to establish what happened.”
“I did my job.”
Patricia looked at him steadily.
“Doing your job is not an answer to a question about how you performed it.”
For the first time, Miller appeared genuinely angry.
“You think I went out there looking for trouble?”
“I haven't reached a conclusion about your motives.”
“That's what this feels like.”
“Then let's return to the facts.”
Patricia asked him to describe the moment immediately before he handcuffed Jordan. Miller repeated that Jordan had been argumentative and uncooperative. When asked for the exact words or actions that constituted resistance, he struggled to identify any.
Finally, Patricia asked about the person near the sedan.
“Have you spoken with that individual since the incident?”
“No.”
“Do you know their name?”
“No.”
“Have you received any calls or messages from them?”
“No.”
“Has anyone asked you to contact them?”
“No.”
Patricia closed her notebook.
“Thank you. We may need to speak again after the digital review is complete.”
Miller stood.
“Am I suspended?”
“That decision has not been made.”
“Am I being accused of lying?”
“We are reviewing discrepancies. You will have an opportunity to respond to any material findings.”
He seemed dissatisfied with the answer.
At the door, he turned back.
“I hope you understand that every time an officer gets investigated, it makes the rest of us look bad.”
Patricia met his gaze.
“If the investigation is fair, it should help distinguish officers who follow the rules from those who do not. That protects the public, and it protects honest officers.”
Miller said nothing.
After he left, Patricia remained seated. She replayed several moments from the interview in her mind. His answers had been vague, but vagueness alone did not prove dishonesty. The key was whether the recordings and other evidence could establish what he had known, when he had known it, and why he had acted as he did.
She wrote one final note.
Obtain all available neighborhood footage before drawing conclusions about the unidentified individual.
By midafternoon, the investigation had produced its first significant lead.
A small convenience store stood at the corner of the street where Miller's patrol car had stopped. The store's exterior camera covered part of the sidewalk and the road. Its owner, a middle-aged man named Samuel Price, initially seemed reluctant to become involved.
“I don't want trouble,” Samuel told Patricia when she visited the shop.
“I understand,” she said. “We're not asking you to take sides. We are asking whether your camera recorded an event that may be relevant to an official investigation.”
Samuel glanced toward the shelves.
“People get angry when they think you're helping the police. Other people get angry when they think you're not helping the police. Either way, my store is the one that gets caught in the middle.”
Patricia did not dismiss his concern.
“We will document what we request and how the footage is handled. You don't need to speculate about what it means. Just allow us to preserve the original recording.”
After a moment, Samuel nodded.
He brought her into a small office behind the counter and opened the camera system. The footage was grainy but usable. Patricia watched as the patrol car approached the corner.
The person beside the sedan was clearer from this angle.
He was a man wearing a dark jacket and a baseball cap. He appeared to speak briefly toward the patrol car's open window. Miller's face was partly visible through the glass.
The man then pointed down the street.
Miller nodded.
The exchange lasted only a few seconds.
The man walked away before the patrol car moved toward Jordan's house.
Patricia watched the sequence again.
“Can we see the earlier footage?” she asked.
Samuel adjusted the playback controls.
Several minutes before Miller arrived, the same man had been standing near the corner, looking toward Jordan's driveway. He had made a phone call, paced along the sidewalk, and returned to the parked sedan.
Then the patrol car appeared.
Patricia leaned closer to the monitor.
“Can you export this section, including the five minutes before the vehicle arrives?”
“Sure.”
“And please preserve the original recording.”
Samuel nodded.
As the file copied, Patricia asked whether he recognized the man.
Samuel hesitated.
“I've seen him before.”
“Do you know his name?”