He gathered the documents into a folder — the survey plat on top, the rulebook beneath it, the work order in a clear plastic sleeve so the signature would not smudge, the photographs printed and saved on a USB drive, the notebook with the times, the insurance paperwork from the pool with the four-thousand-dollar deductible circled in red ink. He showered, changed, and drove to Elena's office with the folder on the passenger seat beside him.
Her office was on the second floor of a brick building downtown, quiet and orderly, and she was waiting in a conference room with a file open in front of her. She asked him to tell the whole story from the beginning and took notes, stopping him only to clarify a date or a number. When he finished, she spread the documents out and went through them one by one, comparing the survey to the rulebook, the work order to the photographs, the times in his notebook to the timestamps on the camera footage. When she came to the photograph of the tape measure showing twelve feet, she tapped it with her pen.
"This is your strongest piece of evidence from today," she said. "Not the broken fence. Not the bulldozer. This measurement. Because it is simple, and it is objective, and it cannot be argued away. Twelve feet is more than ten feet. Anyone can understand that. A judge can understand that. Vanessa Whitmore ordered the demolition of a compliant fence. That is the fact at the centre of this, and everything else we build will rest on it."
The letter would set out the pool contamination and the fence demolition as a single pattern, cite the HOA's own rules — including the requirement for notice and a hearing before enforcement — demand that the HOA cease all action against his property and pay for the fence repair and the pool remediation, preserve all records, and put Vanessa Whitmore on notice personally as well as in her capacity as president, and state that all further communication was to go through Elena.
"It will cost seven thousand two hundred dollars," she said again, looking him directly in the eye. "If the case continues, the cost could rise to twelve thousand five hundred dollars. I will keep you informed at every stage so you can decide whether to proceed. But the paper trail is getting stronger, not weaker. The pool, the offer, the deductible, the bulldozer, the measurement. Each piece supports the next. We should use it while it is fresh."
Darius thought about the morning he had just lived through, standing barefoot in his yard at six o'clock, and about what would happen if he did nothing — if he fixed the fence himself and waited for whatever came next. The thought was more frightening than the legal bill. He nodded. "Send it. Write it and send it. I am not going to be intimidated out of my own home."
"Then we will proceed," Elena said. "I will have a draft for you by tomorrow morning. And from this point on, do not speak to Vanessa Whitmore or the HOA board about this. If anyone from the HOA contacts you, refer them to me. That is what you are paying for: a buffer, and a record. It is much harder to bully a lawyer than a homeowner standing barefoot in his yard at dawn."
That sense of steadiness lasted until the afternoon, when his phone rang from a number he did not recognise. A smooth, practised voice introduced himself as Mark Delaney, lawyer for Vanessa Whitmore and for the HOA.
"Mr. Cole, I am calling on behalf of my client, Vanessa Whitmore, and the Briarwood Estates Homeowners Association. I understand there has been an unfortunate misunderstanding this morning regarding your fence, and I understand you have also made certain allegations regarding your pool. I am calling to see if we can resolve this matter quickly and quietly, without the need for formal proceedings, which I am sure we can both agree would be costly and unpleasant for everyone involved."
Darius kept his voice level. "I am represented by counsel, Mr. Delaney. My lawyer is Elena Vasquez. You should direct any communication to her. I am not going to discuss this matter with you directly."
Delaney chuckled, a short, dry sound meant to sound friendly. "Of course. I will certainly be in touch with Ms. Vasquez. But I thought it might be helpful for us to have a brief, informal conversation first, man to man, before the lawyers get involved and the costs start to mount. I understand Ms. Vasquez has quoted you a considerable fee for a letter. Seven thousand dollars, I believe, perhaps more if this continues. That is a great deal of money for a fence dispute, Mr. Cole. My client would hate to see you spend that kind of money when this could be resolved much more simply."