HOA President Dumped Rotten Food Into a Black Homeowner's Pool — Then Her Master Key Exposed a Bigger Crime at the Police Station

Chapter 6

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

He went back to his closing papers, to the disclosure forms, to the inspection report from before the sale, and found the line that described the fence — its height, its material, its condition, its color — all noted, all signed, all part of the record of what he had bought. The fence had been disclosed, inspected, and approved as part of the sale. He made copies of all of it.

Then he wrote his reply, the same way he had written the first one, plainly, with facts, with dates, with citations, with copies attached. He stated that he had not painted the fence, that the fence predated his ownership, that it had been built to specification and disclosed at sale, and that the association's own rules protected pre-existing structures. He asked, politely, for the association to cite the clause that made a pre-existing, disclosed, previously approved fence a violation in the hands of a new owner, and stated that he would comply with any rule that was properly cited and properly applied. He kept a copy, mailed it certified, and put the receipt in the folder.

And again, the fine vanished. Silently. No apology. No correction. No letter saying, Mr. Cole, you were right, the fence was pre-existing, we withdraw the notice. Just silence, as if the notice had never been sent, as if the thirty days had never been counted down. Darius checked the mail every day for a week, waiting for an acknowledgment that never came, then stopped checking, put the papers in the folder, closed the drawer, and told himself, again, that it was over.

He wanted to believe it was a pattern of mistakes, that the association was disorganized, that a new president was learning the job, that a clerk was sending notices without checking the files. He was a logical man, and logic told him to look for the simplest explanation first, and the simplest explanation was incompetence. Incompetence was common, human, forgivable. He did not want to believe that the president of his homeowners association, a woman who had welcomed him with a smile and a binder, was using fines as a tool, sending notices she knew would not hold up, counting on a new homeowner to pay rather than fight, to repaint rather than reply, to move his van rather than cite the rules. He did not want to believe that, because believing it would change the way he lived in his own house, and he had bought the house to live in peace.

But then the third notice came, and the simplest explanation stopped being simple.

This time it was the height. The back fence, the same fence, the one that had been too brown and then had not been too brown, was now, according to the notice, two inches too tall. Two inches. Darius read the number and stared at it, because two inches was such a small number, and such a precise number, and it suggested that someone had been out there with a tape measure in his backyard, looking for a reason. The notice said the fence exceeded the maximum height allowed, a fine would be assessed, and the fence would need to be lowered, at the homeowner's expense, within thirty days.

Darius went out to the backyard with his own tape measure, the steel one he used for work, the one that did not stretch, and measured the fence himself, post by post, section by section, in the heat of the afternoon, his shirt sticking to his back. He measured from the ground, from the high side and the low side, because a yard is never perfectly level, and wrote each number down in his notebook. When he was done, he stood back and looked at the fence. It was the same height it had been when he bought the house, the same height it had been when the previous owner built it, to the association's specifications, with a permit, with an inspection, with a record. It had not grown. Fences do not grow. It had not been raised. He had not raised it. It was, to the inch, the fence that had been there all along.

He went inside and found the original specifications the previous owner had followed, still in the association's own files, and the permit, and the inspection report that had signed off on the height, and the closing disclosure that listed the fence as it stood. He laid them out on the kitchen table, side by side, and looked at them for a long time, and felt the cold, clear attention settling in his chest again, stronger this time. This was not a mistake about a color, and it was not a mistake about a van. This was a fence that had been built right, measured right, approved right, and now it was suddenly two inches too tall, and the only thing that had changed was who owned the house.

News in the same category

HOA President Dumped Rotten Food Into a Black Homeowner's Pool — Then Her Master Key Exposed a Bigger Crime at the Police Station

45 Part