I Drained My Pool — Then Karen Returned With The Cops Claiming It Was Hers

Chapter 3

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Then came the excavation, and I will confess that this is the part I still think about when I cannot sleep. They arrived on a Tuesday morning in May with equipment that made the whole street vibrate, and by noon there was a hole in my back yard where the grass had been. It was an ugly hole. It was the ugliest beautiful thing I had ever seen. The neighbors came out to look at it the way people look at an accident — with a kind of appalled fascination — and Mrs. Abernathy from number 12 brought me a casserole, which I understood to be a gesture of solidarity with anyone whose property had been temporarily converted into a construction site.

The concrete shell went in next, sprayed over steel in a process called shotcrete, and I stood on the deck with a cup of coffee and watched two men in masks build the walls of my pool the way you might watch someone lay the foundation of a house you intend to live in forever. The tile came after: a border at the waterline, cobalt blue, each piece set by hand. I chose the color the way I choose everything — deliberately, after looking at samples in three different lights — and I have never once regretted it. Then the coping, the pale concrete edge you sit on with your legs in the water. Then the decking. Then the equipment: the pump, the filter, the heater I almost didn't buy and have used exactly as often as I predicted, which is to say, constantly.

The first fill took two days. I stood at the kitchen window and watched the water rise, inch by inch, over the tile, over the steps, over the bench in the deep end, until the whole twenty-two by forty-four feet of it was blue and still and mine. I remember the date. I remember the weather. I remember standing at the edge in bare feet and putting one toe in, the way you do, and thinking: this is the largest check I have ever written, and it is also the only one I have ever written that made me want to cry.

The cost was significant. I will not give you the figure, because the figure belongs to me and to the file, but I will tell you that it was significant and that it was budgeted — there is a difference, and the difference is everything. I had saved for it for years. I had modeled it. I had a line item in the annual budget for maintenance, and I have funded that line item every year for twelve years, and the line item has never once been a problem, because that is what a line item is for.

The maintenance itself I contracted out from the beginning, to a pool service company that sent a man named Doug every Tuesday for twelve years. Doug is a person of few words and many opinions about chlorine, and he kept that pool in a condition that I can only describe as professionally immaculate. Every Tuesday he tested the water, balanced the chemicals, skimmed, vacuumed, backwashed the filter, and left an invoice on the kitchen counter. Every Tuesday I initialed it and filed it. There are six hundred and twenty-four of those invoices in the file, or near enough that I am comfortable rounding. Six hundred and twenty-four Tuesdays of someone taking care of something I loved, and me paying for it on time, every time, because that is what you do with things that are yours.

There was a rhythm to the year, too, that I came to depend on. Every October, Doug would come with the winterizing kit — not a full drain, just the lowering, the plugs, the cover, the careful chemistry of putting water to sleep — and every April he would reverse it, and I would stand on the deck and watch the cover come off and feel the small, private thrill of a season opening its account. The draining, when it happened, was mine to order. It was maintenance. It was scheduled. It was, in every sense that matters, my decision, the way the filling had been my decision and the tile had been my decision and the six hundred and twenty-four invoices had been my decision.

And what did I get for it? This is the question people ask, sometimes, the ones who do the math out loud at dinner parties — the cost per swim, as if a pool were a vending machine. I have an answer for them, and it is not a number.

I got the evening light. Anyone who has owned a pool knows the specific hour I mean: late, in July, when the sun drops low enough to hit the water at an angle and the whole surface goes the color of hammered copper, and the tile border glows, and you can hear the filter humming its low, contented note from behind the fence. I spent hundreds of those evenings in that water, or beside it, and I cannot tell you what I was thinking during most of them, which is precisely the point. An accountant's mind does not turn off easily. Mine turns off in a pool.

I got the chlorine smell — clean, sharp, honest — the smell of a thing being maintained. I got Saturday afternoons with a book, the pages going soft at the edges from the humidity, reading in the shade of the umbrella while the water lapped at the coping in a rhythm I could set my breathing to. I got weeknight swims after long days of reconciling other people's numbers: twenty minutes of slow laps, the water holding me up, the day's columns dissolving behind me like ink in water. I got the sound of rain on the surface, which is different from rain on anything else — a million tiny impacts, all at once, like applause from very far away.

I got mornings, too, early ones, when the water was glass and the steam came off it in October and I would stand on the deck with coffee and look at the thing I had built and feel something I am too precise a person to call anything but what it was: pride. Not the loud kind. The quiet kind. The kind that comes from a receipt with your name on it and twelve years of Tuesdays and a tile border you chose in three different lights.

No spreadsheet could capture what the pool returned. I know this because I tried, once, in the idle way of a person who makes spreadsheets the way other people doodle. I made a column for cost and a column for swims and a column for evenings and a column for the way the light looked, and the sheet would not balance, and it was the only unbalanced sheet I have ever been happy to leave unbalanced. Some things appreciate in a currency that has no code.

I was not, for the record, a miser about the pool. I had friends over for it. I held a fortieth birthday there with string lights and a cake that leaned slightly to the left, and I invited the Abernathys' grandchildren when they visited in August, and I let my colleague Maren bring her twins for an afternoon, because sharing a thing you own, on your own terms, by invitation, is one of the genuine pleasures of owning it. The key words are on your own terms. The key words are by invitation. I mention this now because it will matter later, when someone else starts using those key words and leaving them out in the same breath.

For twelve years, the pool was simply there — the center of my summers, the quiet of my evenings, the largest and most deliberate purchase of my adult life, maintained weekly, documented thoroughly, and loved in the steady, unsentimental way of a person who does not say "I love you" to objects but who initials six hundred and twenty-four invoices without ever once resenting a single one of them.

That was before Sandra. That was when the pool was only mine, and only beautiful, and only a story about a woman who wanted something for a long time and then did the work and paid the money and kept the receipts.

I want you to hold that image — the water at evening, the tile glowing, the filter humming — because everything that follows is about what happened when someone else decided that image belonged to her, too.


The New Neighbor

Sandra Fielding moved into 16 Cloverfield Road on a Saturday in March, which I know because I keep a notebook by the kitchen window — not for anything dramatic, just dates — and because moving trucks are difficult to overlook when they are parked across your driveway for four hours. She arrived with two young children, a boy and a girl, who were then about seven and nine, and with what I can only describe as a full inventory of opinions about the neighborhood, which she began distributing to anyone within earshot before the truck was fully unloaded.

I should be fair here, because the story I am telling requires Sandra to be a real person and not a cartoon, and she is a real person. She is specific. That is what made her difficult, in the end — not that she was a villain in a general sense, but that she was Sandra Fielding in every particular, and the particulars added up.

She talks the way some people drive: fast, with strong opinions about the lane she is in, and with a horn she is not afraid to use. Her sentences tend to arrive with their conclusions first. "The mailboxes on this street are a disgrace" was, I believe, her opening remark to Mrs. Abernathy, delivered within the first week, across the hedge, at a volume that suggested she considered the whole street her audience. She had views on the Hendersons' lawn, which she described as "a cry for help." She had views on the speed of the cars on Cloverfield Road, the placement of the recycling bins, the color of the new shutters at number 8 — "a choice," she said, in the tone of a person rendering a verdict — and the general decline, as she saw it, of people who did not maintain their properties to what she called "a standard." The irony of that last one would become apparent to me much later, and I have had to sit with it quietly, because there is no dignified way to enjoy irony that arrives at someone else's expense.

News in the same category

I Drained My Pool — Then Karen Returned With The Cops Claiming It Was Hers

20 Part