I stood there for a while, looking at the wet deck, and I did what I always do when something does not reconcile. I started at the beginning and worked forward.
I began keeping a log. Dated, timed, observed — the way you document anything you might need to refer to later, in language a third party could follow. Over the remaining weeks of September I logged seventeen occasions on which the pool had clearly been used and I had not been home. Seventeen. I want to be precise about this, because precision is the only thing that kept me calm: seventeen separate occasions, and on nine of them there was evidence of people I did not know — extra towels, unfamiliar sunscreen, a child's inflatable ring in a size neither of Sandra's children would use, a paperback novel with a cracked spine left on the table, abandoned mid-chapter by someone who did not live here.
Seventeen times, Sandra had brought people to swim in my pool while I was not there.
Which raised the question I had been avoiding, the way you avoid looking directly at the one line in the ledger that will not balance no matter how many times you re-add it: how were they getting in?
The gate to the pool area locks. It has always locked. I am careful about this — a pool is an attractive nuisance, as the lawyers say, and I am an accountant, and between the two professions we have the risk covered from both sides. The key hangs on a hook inside the pool shed. The shed locks too, but during the Tuesday maintenance visits I leave it open, because the technician needs access to the equipment pad, and I am home on Tuesdays. I was home on Tuesdays that summer.
There had been a Tuesday in August — I fixed the date later, the way you fix a date when it matters: August 18th. The technician was servicing the filter. Sandra had come over with the children for their swim — by then it was simply the routine, the way the mail comes — and at some point, while I was inside on a work call, Sandra had gone into the shed. For what, I don't know. A towel, she might have said, if anyone had asked. The spare key hung on its hook by the door, in plain sight, exactly where it had hung for twelve years.
After that Tuesday, I noticed — and this is the detail I am least proud of noticing, because it means I was already suspicious and already keeping score — that the key was not hanging straight. It was on the hook, but turned a quarter rotation, as if it had been taken down and replaced in a hurry. A small thing. The kind of thing you notice when you are the kind of person who notices where things hang. I straightened it without thinking, the way you straighten a picture frame, and then I stood there in the shed for a full minute, thinking about why I had needed to straighten it at all.
I do not know, even now, whether she took the key or copied it or simply noted where it was kept. What I know is this: after August 18th, the pool was used seventeen times when I was not home, and the gate was never forced, and the fence was never climbed — I would have seen the marks; I know what a climbed fence looks like — and so the key, in whatever form, had found its way to the other side of the fence.
I sat with that for a few days. I am not a confrontational person. I have never raised my voice in a professional setting, and I have been in professional settings that would have justified it twice over. But I am also not a person who lets a variance go unexplained. That is the whole of my job, really: finding the number that does not belong and asking, politely and relentlessly, where it came from.
By the end of September, I had my numbers. Seventeen occasions. One key, relocated. And a word — occasionally — that had been stretched so thin you could see through it, like a grocery bag carrying too much.
I decided it was time to have a conversation with my neighbor.
The Conversation
I chose a Saturday morning, because Saturday mornings are neutral territory — no one is rushing to work, no one is tired from it yet, and the light is forgiving. I invited Sandra for coffee on my patio. I said I wanted to talk about the pool and the summer, and I kept my voice exactly as I keep it in meetings where the numbers are bad: even, unhurried, giving nothing away before its time.
She came at ten, in a bright yellow top, carrying a small plate of banana bread she had baked, which complicated things slightly, because it is harder to be firm with a person who has brought you banana bread. I accepted it graciously. We sat by the pool — my pool, still and blue and, for once that summer, empty — and we talked about the weather for exactly as long as politeness required. Then I set down my cup.
"Sandra," I said, "I need to talk to you about the pool."
I had rehearsed this. Not the words so much as the order of them, because order matters. I told her first what I appreciated: that the children were good children, that I had enjoyed having them here in June, that I meant it when I said it. Then I told her what had changed, and I used numbers, because numbers are harder to argue with than feelings. Four days a week in July. Five in August, plus guests I had not met. And then September: seventeen occasions on which the pool had been used while I was not home.
I watched her face as I said seventeen. There was a flicker — surprise, I think, or calculation; it is hard to tell the two apart in real time — and then a smoothing, the way water settles after something has been dropped in it.
"I also know about the key," I said. "The spare, from the shed. I noticed it had been moved during the maintenance visit on August 18th, and the gate has been opened repeatedly since then without being forced. I'd like it back, please. And I'd like the swimming to go back to what we originally discussed — occasionally, with you present."
There. It was out. I had said it the way I say difficult things to clients: directly, without accusation, leaving the other person a clean path to the right answer. I am told this is a skill. It has taken me twenty-four years to develop it, and I deployed it that morning the way a surgeon deploys a scalpel — carefully, and with the hope that it would not be necessary to cut deep.