how quickly a family can become a story people enjoy repeating.” I heard the threat beneath the sentence. Finch did too. She stood. “This interview is over.” Outside, I asked her why she had not arrested him. “Because suspicion is not probable cause,” she said. “He will know we're coming now.” “He already knew.” “Then we have to make our next move before he does.” On the pavement, a young man in a gray cap approached me and handed me a folded piece of paper.
He did not stop walking. The note contained six words: Agnes is alive. Ask about the chapel. I turned, but the man had disappeared into the courthouse crowd. Finch read the note and immediately called her team. “There is an old chapel at St. Anne's,” she said. “It was closed after the maternity wing moved. If Agnes is there, we need to find her before Vail does.”
The old chapel stood behind the hospital's original brick building, its stained-glass windows boarded from the inside. The maternity ward had been demolished, but the chapel remained, partly hidden by a new parking structure. Finch obtained permission to search the property. The hospital administrator insisted no one had entered the building in years. We found Agnes in a locked side room, sitting on the floor with a blanket around her shoulders. Her wrists were bruised. She was alive, dehydrated, and furious that the police had taken so long. When she saw me, she said, “You should have brought Lydia.” I knelt beside her. “We can call her.” “Not yet. I need to tell you what I didn't tell you at the café.” An ambulance crew arrived to examine her. Agnes refused to leave until Finch promised that Wren was safe. Then she told us that Vail had approached her at her apartment and asked for the original Northstar ledger.
When she refused, two men took her to the chapel. They wanted to know where Wren was. Agnes had lied. “They said they knew the child had reached Briar House,” she told Finch. “They asked whether Margaret had left other records.” “Did you tell them?” “I told them I had burned everything.” She looked at me. “I did not.” The ambulance crew helped her onto a stretcher. Before the doors closed, Agnes caught my wrist. “Your grandmother built the passage for a reason. There is more inside the wall than a place to hide.” I thought of the small chamber behind the wardrobe. “What is there?” “A map,” she said. “And a list of the families.” At Briar House, we dismantled the lower shelf inside the passage. Wren watched from the hallway, holding Emma's hand. The board lifted to reveal a narrow drawer. Inside lay a cloth-wrapped bundle. It contained a hand-drawn plan of the house, a brass key, and a list of seven names.
Each name had a date, a hospital, and a small symbol beside it. Wren's name was the last. The first belonged to a boy born eleven months before her. The second to a girl from a county hospital. The remaining names were scattered across three towns and two states. At the bottom, Margaret had written: Children transferred through Northstar. Families not yet reunited. “There are more,” Lydia whispered. I looked at the list. The crime was not just ours. It was a pattern, and each name was a life rearranged by adults who had decided that a child could be moved like property. Wren touched one of the entries. “Do they know where their mummies are?” she asked. I did not know how to answer. “Some may,” I said. “Some may not.” “Can we tell them?” Lydia looked at me, then at Finch. “We can try,” Finch said. “But first we need to verify every name and make sure the families are ready to hear.”
Wren nodded solemnly. “Then tell the first one.”
The map led us to a narrow stairwell between the study and the west bedroom. It had been sealed with plaster and wallpaper decades earlier. The brass key opened a small lock concealed behind the skirting board. When I pulled the door, a current of cold air rose from below. The passage descended into a storage cellar that had been closed off during a renovation in the nineteen-fifties. Margaret had used it as an archive. There were shelves of boxes, a desk, a filing cabinet, and a small safe bolted to the stone wall. The room smelled of damp paper and candle wax. On the desk lay a notebook with Margaret's handwriting, and beside it a photograph of Arthur, Margaret, and Dr. Rusk standing outside the Northstar office. They looked like people posing for a community newsletter. I hated how ordinary they appeared.