A small battery lantern sat on the floor. There were two folded blankets, a plastic cup, a tin of crackers, a child’s picture book, and a pair of tiny shoes. Someone had been using the space. I held the candle higher. At the far end, a little girl crouched with her knees against her chest. Her hair was cut unevenly at the chin. She wore a blue sweater too large for her, and one sock had a hole at the heel. Her eyes moved from my face to the pry bar in my hand. I lowered it at once. “It’s all right,” I said. “I’m not going to hurt you.” She did not move. “What’s your name?” I asked. Her mouth opened, but no sound came. Behind me, Lydia made a small, broken noise. I turned toward her. She was staring at the child, and the color had drained from her face. The girl looked back at me.
Then she lifted one hand and touched the pale crescent-shaped birthmark just below my left collarbone, the mark I had carried since childhood and hidden from the sun. Her own collar had slipped aside. Beneath it, on the same side of her small chest, was an identical crescent, pale against her skin. “Daddy?” she whispered. The word seemed to strike the room like a falling glass. Lydia collapsed.
For several seconds I could not move. The candle flame trembled between my hand and the open wall. The girl had said one word, and my wife lay on the floor as if someone had cut the strings holding her upright. I dropped to my knees beside Lydia, checked her breathing, and called her name. Her eyes were open, but she was not looking at me. Emma appeared at the far end of the hall in her pajamas, frightened by the noise. I told her to go to the neighbor’s house and ask Mrs. Alvarez to call emergency services. She hesitated. “Dad—” “Now, sweetheart.” She ran. I turned back to the hidden passage. The little girl had pressed herself against the wall. “You’re not in trouble,” I said. “Can you tell me your name?” “Wren.” Her voice was so soft I had to lean closer. “How old are you, Wren?” She held up seven fingers, then lowered one as if uncertain. “Seven in the winter.”
“Who brought you here?” She looked past me to Lydia. “The lady said this was your house.” “What lady?” “Miss Agnes.” I felt the name settle in my stomach. Agnes Bell. My grandmother’s letter. Lydia stirred, and I helped her sit up. She stared at Wren as if she were seeing a photograph develop in front of her. “Is it really you?” she whispered. Wren nodded once. “Mummy said you would know.” Lydia covered her face. I had never seen my wife look so afraid. The paramedics arrived within twelve minutes. They checked Lydia, who insisted she did not need an ambulance, and examined Wren for injuries and dehydration. The girl flinched when one of them reached toward her, so I asked them to let her keep hold of my sleeve. It was the first time she had touched me. She held the fabric between two fingers, not quite trusting it.
Emma returned with Mrs. Alvarez, who took one look at the open wardrobe and the child and said nothing. By midnight, Lydia was in bed with a glass of water and a doctor’s instruction to rest. Wren sat at the kitchen table wrapped in a blanket, eating toast in tiny bites. Emma had fallen asleep on the sofa, her rabbit tucked beneath her chin. I stood opposite Wren, trying to understand how a child I had never seen could have my birthmark and call me Daddy. “Did you know my name?” I asked. She nodded. “Nathan.” “Who told you?” “Miss Agnes. She showed me your picture.” “Why did you think I was your father?” Wren looked down at the toast. “Because she said you were.” I sat slowly. “Did she tell you anything else?” Wren pressed her thumb against the crescent mark at her collarbone. “She said you lost me, but you didn’t stop looking.” I had stopped breathing.
I wanted to ask a hundred questions, but the first one came out as a whisper. “When did I lose you?” Wren looked up. “When I was a baby.” Upstairs, a floorboard creaked. Lydia was awake. I could hear her crying through the ceiling.