No letters. No second photograph. No document with the name Daniel Whitmore on it. Nothing that explained why my mother had changed his name when she talked about him, or why she had torn his face out of the picture, or why she had kept the ring in the image and destroyed the rest of the man. The filing cabinet gave up only the familiar paper trail of our life together: property tax bills, the deed to the house, insurance forms with my mother's trembling later signature, a folder of medical receipts from the nine days in intensive care that I could not bring myself to read. The boxes in the spare room held old curtains, a set of dishes we never used, a quilt my grandmother had made, things that belonged to the ordinary business of a household and nothing that belonged to the secret. It was as if my mother had swept the house clean of Daniel with the same thoroughness she had once swept the kitchen floor, and the only thing she had missed was the drawer where she kept the photograph, and the attic she had never expected me to climb into.
Then I remembered the attic.
The pull-down stairs had not been opened since my mother died. I had avoided them the way I avoided the bedroom, not because I was afraid of what was up there, but because going up meant admitting that the house was mine now in a way that could not be undone. I stood in the hallway and looked up at the panel in the ceiling, and then I reached up and pulled the cord, and the stairs unfolded with a groan I felt in my teeth, and a rush of warm, dusty air came down over my face.
Dust covered everything up there. It lay thick on the boxes and the beams, and it rose in clouds around my shoes as I climbed, catching the light from the single bare bulb in golden drifts. The air smelled of old paper and cedar and something faintly sweet, like the lavender sachets my mother used to tuck into drawers. Christmas decorations in cracked plastic bins. Baby clothes folded in a trunk, tiny and impossibly small, the fabric soft with age — a knitted cardigan no bigger than my hand, a pair of booties with the yarn worn thin at the toes. I touched them and thought about the baby who had worn them, and about the mother who had folded them away so carefully instead of throwing them out, and I understood that my mother had never thrown anything away that mattered. She had only hidden it where she thought I would not look. Old gardening tools with worn wooden handles. A sewing basket with spools of thread in colors my mother had not used in years. And in the far corner, half hidden behind a stack of blankets, a suitcase.
It was old, the leather scuffed and the latches tarnished, and when I dragged it out into the light and lifted the lid, my hands stopped shaking, because what was inside was not what I had expected at all.
Hundreds of envelopes. Stacked in rows, packed tight, their edges yellowed with age. Every single one of them addressed, in handwriting I did not recognize, to the same name.
Emma Sarah Whitmore.
I opened the first letter sitting on the attic floor with dust on my jeans and the suitcase open beside me, and the light from the bare bulb falling over my hands.
The earliest had been written when I was four.
My sweet Emma,
I don't know if Sarah will ever let you read these, but I promised myself I would write anyway.
Today you are four.
I remember the way you used to press your little hands against speakers to feel music.
You thought vibration was magic.
Maybe it is.
Your mother says you're learning signs faster than both of us.
I wish I were there to learn with you.
I'm sorry.
I turned the page, and there at the bottom, drawn in careful, clumsy lines, were hands forming simple signs. The fingers were wrong in places, the way a beginner's fingers are wrong, but the intention was unmistakable, and someone had labeled each drawing in neat block letters underneath.
LOVE.
DAD.
EMMA.
My vision blurred, and I had to set the letter down on my knee and press the heels of my hands against my eyes until I could see again. A man I had been taught to hate had sat somewhere, at some time I could not picture, and drawn hands for his four-year-old daughter, hands shaped like love, so that she might one day learn the word from him even if she never met him.
I held my own hands up in the dusty attic light and tried the signs myself, copying the drawings the way a child copies letters from a book. LOVE: both arms crossed over the chest, fists closed, the way my mother had taught me years later, though I had never known who had taught her the shape of it first. DAD: thumb against the forehead, a small tap, a word I had never signed for anyone, because there had never been anyone to sign it to. EMMA: my own name, drawn in a stranger's hand, as if he had practiced it the way you practice a name you are afraid of forgetting. My fingers were clumsy with it, and the clumsiness made my throat close, because his drawings had been clumsy too, and for the first time I understood that we had been clumsy together, across twenty years and a wall of silence, learning the same language from opposite ends of it.