You keep saying you failed to see it, she said at last. "I want you to notice that Lily did see it, and she is six, and she had no one to tell who would believe her except Grace, and Grace—" She stopped. "Grace told me at Christmas she was worried. Did you know that? She called me. She said Lily had started hiding her father's teacups. Emptying them into the sink plant when Nora wasn't looking. A six-year-old, running a counterinsurgency out of a sink plant." Her laugh broke in the middle. "The plant died, Ethan. We thought it was funny. I told Grace it was a phase."
Through the kitchen window he could see Lily bent over the planets, her tongue caught between her teeth in concentration, the rabbit propped against the sugar bowl like a colleague.
She stays here as long as it takes, Rachel said. "I'll take leave. Mark will take leave. The school has already been told she's with family — no details, and the principal owes me approximately four hundred favors. Nobody gets past me, Ethan. Nobody gets past my porch. You go and do the lawyers and the police and the company, and you come here every evening and you eat dinner at that table like a person, and when it's over—" She looked at him then, fierce and wet-eyed, his big sister, who had taught him to tie his shoes and to throw a punch and in which order those skills should be used. "When it's over, you and I are going to have a conversation about loneliness. Not tonight. But it's coming."
I know, he said.
Good, she said. "Then go wash your face. Your daughter can read a face like a weather map, and you look like a hurricane."
He found the sketchbook on the fourth evening, because Lily asked him to.
She had settled into Rachel's house with the grave adaptability of a child who had already learned once that homes could change overnight. She slept in the spare room with the rabbit and a nightlight shaped like a moon. She ate Rachel's cooking with the focused appetite of the very tired. She did her jigsaws, she drew at the kitchen table for hours with her box of pencils ranked by color like a small army, and she did not ask about the house, or the tea, or Nora — except once, at bath time, to Rachel, who reported it to Ethan verbatim, standing in the hallway with a wet towel over her shoulder: "Aunt Rachel, is Nora allowed to be sorry? Because if she says sorry properly, does Daddy have to drink it then?" And Rachel had said, "No, baby. Never. Not any of it, not ever again," and Lily had nodded and gone back to her bath boats as if a treaty had been signed.
On the fourth evening, after dinner, Lily climbed down from her chair, went to the spare room, and returned carrying a sketchbook Ethan recognized with a jolt — a birthday present from Grace, its cover printed with stars, its spine already softening. She placed it on the table in front of him with both hands, the way she had once seen him place a contract in front of a client, and said, "You can look at all of it. Even the back ones. I don't mind now."
Lily, he said carefully, "these are yours. You don't have to show me."
I drew them so somebody would know, she said, with devastating simplicity. "But nobody looked. You can look now. You're the somebody."
Rachel, at the sink, went very still with her hands in the water.
He opened the book.
The early pages were ordinary — gloriously, heartbreakingly ordinary. A house with smoke coming out of the chimney in spirals. A cat she did not own. Sarah, drawn the way she had drawn her for two years now, with long yellow hair and a blue dress and arms wide, in a garden, under a sun with a face. Then, page by page, as he turned them, the year of his marriage unspooled in a child's pencil, and Ethan felt the kitchen tilt slowly around him.
Nora standing at the counter, drawn tall, her hair a black scribble, holding a cup out — and in the cup, Lily had drawn wavy lines rising, and colored them green. Green, months ago, before there had ever been green vapor on his marble floor for anyone to see. Ethan's hand stopped on the page. He made himself turn it.
Nora on the telephone, the phone an enormous black rectangle pressed to her ear, and out of her mouth a speech bubble, and in the bubble — no words, Lily could barely write — a drawing of a bed, and a man in the bed, and over the man a long, careful X. Page after page. Nora locking a drawer: the drawer rendered with a huge keyhole, Nora's hand with a key, Lily herself tiny in the corner of the page, in a doorway, watching — she had drawn herself watching, again and again, small in doorways, behind the banister rails rendered as prison bars of vertical lines, at the crack of the kitchen door. In one drawing the whole family sat at the table and everyone's face was smiling except Lily's, and Nora's hand, beneath the table where the grown-ups in the picture could not see, held the little brown bottle.
He turned the pages and the bottle was everywhere. Behind the flour tin — she had drawn the tin, labeled it in her staggering first-grade letters, FLOUR, and behind it the bottle, colored brown, with a white cap. On the counter beside the teapot. Once, terribly, in Nora's handbag, the bag drawn open like a mouth.