‘If I Sing Well, Will You Give Me Food’ A Black Street Girl Asked at a Talent Show — And Then The Judge Laughed

Chapter 14

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

I've been advised to wait, she said, pleasantly, into the lights. "So I'm going to wait."

The producer's smile reorganized itself. Somewhere behind the glass, she imagined, a pen was being set down.

They put it on the call sheet in type too big to argue with: BATTLE ROUND — JOHNSON vs. KANE.

Everyone understood the assignment. The producers understood it, and the audience understood it, and the internet understood it before the girls had sung a note. The street girl and the rich girl. The duct tape and the designer shoes. In the promo that ran all week, their faces were split down the middle of the screen like a coin, and the announcer said contrast so many times the word wore smooth.

Skylar Kane arrived at rehearsal with a vocal coach, a mother, and a garment bag. Amara arrived with her guitar and a sandwich Mrs. Brooks had made her eat half of on the bus. They were given the same song — a bright pop duet chopped into verses they were meant to fight over — and a choreographer who kept saying "tension, girls, sell me the tension," as if tension were a thing you could buy by the yard.

Amara had prepared herself to dislike Skylar, and the preparation failed immediately, the way it always did when the person turned out to be a person. Skylar was seventeen and tall and had the kind of polish that looks like confidence until you got close enough to see it was varnish. She warmed up in scales so clean they sounded poured. She also apologized to the sound engineer twice, once for existing near his cables.

It was in the stairwell, of all places, between rehearsal and the fitting, that it happened. Amara had gone there because stairwells were quiet and had doors that closed. She was sitting on the third step down with her guitar across her knees, not playing, just holding it, when the door opened and Skylar came in carrying two bottles of water like an offering.

They told me to 'find my motivation,' Skylar said. "My motivation is apparently that you want my life." She sat down, uninvited, two steps up, so they were nearly level. "Do you want my life?"

Which part? Amara said.

Skylar laughed, surprised, and then didn't. She looked at the guitar — the chipped wood, the tape — and her question, when it came, was quiet and not produced. "Is it true? The — all of it. The stations. Your mom."

So Amara told her. Not the television version. The real one, which was smaller and worse: the placement she'd run from at fifteen, the couch months, the shelter lottery, the bagel. The guitar had been her mother's; her mother had been a session singer who'd sung other people's hits in other people's studios and come home humming her own songs that nobody bought. Skylar listened the way the rich are not supposed to be able to listen, with her whole face, and at the end she said, "My mother cried at your audition. She never cries. She has a woman come to the house to prevent crying."

Rich people have everything, Amara said.

We do not, Skylar said, "have a song our mother wrote." She turned her water bottle in her hands. "They want me to sneer at you in the bridge. It's in my notes. 'Sneer.' Like, written down. As if I keep one in my purse."

---

They sang it without the sneer.

The staging had been built for a fight — two platforms, two spotlights, a catwalk of light between them where the confrontation was supposed to bloom. Skylar walked out in silver, Amara in her own clothes, because the stylist's "street look" had been quietly misplaced by Nia and nobody had found it in time. The band started. The first verse was Skylar's, immaculate, and the second was Amara's, rawer, and the song did what songs do when two people stop performing at each other and start performing toward the same place: it changed temperature.

At the bridge — Amara's hands went cold at the word, involuntarily, a memory stored in her fingers — the choreography said step in, circle, face off. Skylar stepped in. She looked at Amara across six inches of stage and television history, and instead of the sneer she did something none of the rehearsals had contained: she dropped to the harmony. Under. Supporting. The note she was famous for, the high one, she gave away, and sang the low line that made Amara's voice the roof of the song.

The audience heard it happen. You could hear them hear it.

In the control room, Philip Grayson said nothing for a moment, and what he finally said to the director was, "Keep it. It's better television," in the tone of a man stepping over something he intended to deal with later.

The judges were kind to the point of confusion. Elena called it the first honest battle of the season. Sloan appraised them both like weather he'd failed to predict. Hale said, "You sang it like it belonged to both of you," and looked, for one unguarded second, like a man listening to a song in another room.

Backstage, a producer with a tablet caught Skylar by the elbow, already composing tomorrow's recap package. "Give me one line about her," he said. "Anything. What it felt like, facing the — you know. The story." He smiled the smile of a man handing her the script one last time, in case she had misplaced it.

Skylar looked at the tablet, and at the corridor where Amara was being photographed against a gray wall. "It felt like singing," she said. "Ask me about the harmony. I worked very hard on the harmony." She walked away before he could write anything down.

They advanced together. In the corridor afterward, among the clipboards and the cables, Skylar's mother embraced her daughter with the stiff gratitude of a woman re-routed mid-argument, and Skylar caught Amara's eye over her shoulder and mouthed, clear as print: No sneer.

Amara mouthed back: None.

News in the same category

‘If I Sing Well, Will You Give Me Food’ A Black Street Girl Asked at a Talent Show — And Then The Judge Laughed

30 Part