‘If I Sing Well, Will You Give Me Food’ A Black Street Girl Asked at a Talent Show — And Then The Judge Laughed

Chapter 27

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The final verse had lived for two years in pencil in a composition notebook, in Amara's handwriting, finished in the small hours at the shelter while the radiators clicked: the verse her mother had been walking toward and never reached, about the door left open, about the road turning, about coming home not to a house but to the people who hum your song back to you when your voice gives out.

Amara sang it into the silence, and her voice did not give out.

At the last line, quietly, under hers — first from the front rows, then row by row, the way it had happened once before — the audience began to hum.

There is a machine for this part, and Amara had watched it from a dressing-room monitor all season: the lights, the music with its heartbeat in it, the host walking the envelope out like it weighed something.

Tonight she stood inside the machine, and it still worked on her. Her palms were damp where they'd rested on her mother's guitar. Tariq had her by the elbow on one side — not holding her up, just *holding*, the way musicians do — and Skylar stood on the other with her shoes still off, her chin high, her hand resting flat between Amara's shoulder blades, steady as a metronome.

The judges' scores came first, and the room counted them like weather. Elena's marks, given through shining eyes. Derek Sloan's, delivered with the strange respect of a man recalculating the value of everything in the room. And Marcus Hale — front of the panel, silver at his temples, a face the country had watched confess the biggest theft of his life and call it by its name — gave his score last, and his voice, when he said her name, was not the cruel judge's voice from the laugh clip. It was just a man's voice, plain and wrecked and honest.

The scores tied. Exactly, arithmetically tied, and the sound the hall made was not cheering — it was that deeper thing, three thousand people understanding at once that the night had handed the decision to *them*, to the phones in their pockets, to the woman at a bus stop in Detroit who had voted eleven times, to the shelter residents crowded around one phone in the kitchen in front of the dartboard.

It had not come easily. Elena's scores had been announced first — high for Skylar's standard, higher for Amara's song, and Elena had not bothered to hide her reasoning: "One of them sang beautifully," she'd said, "and one of them finished a song her dead mother left unfinished, in public, and made it sound like it had always been whole. I know what the harder thing is." Derek Sloan had scored them level, with the dry precision of a man protecting his reputation for cold judgment, and murmured something about the market having spoken all season. And Hale — Hale had given Skylar a nine and Amara a nine, and when the host pressed him on it, the old showman had simply shaken his head and said, "I'm not the story tonight. Add it up." So the panel's arithmetic had landed exactly on the line, and the tie was not a device. It was a fact, standing there on the big screen in white numbers, waiting for the country to break it.

This is correct, Elena said into her microphone, smiling through tears, while the audience roared. "Let the people decide. It was always the people."

The public vote took four minutes that the producers stretched into nine, because this was still television. Amara stood in the lights and did the breathing Elena had taught her, and thought about a photograph in Mrs. Brooks's keeping — her mother at nineteen, laughing, mid-song, caught by somebody's flash — and about how Hale had said, the night of the confession, that he had built a cathedral out of another woman's song and never once asked whose hands had drawn the plans.

Somewhere in the middle of the nine minutes, the host filled the air the way hosts do — the season in review, the journey, the numbers still climbing on a screen she wasn't allowed to see — and Amara found, to her astonishment, that she was calm. Not peaceful, exactly. Finished. She had done the thing the whole season had been bending toward: she had sung her mother's song entire, in a room that had once laughed at her hunger, and the room had hummed it back. Whatever the white numbers said, that part could not be un-sung. Skylar, on her left, was mouthing something to the front row — her parents, Amara realized, in the good seats, her father in a suit that probably cost more than the shelter's monthly budget, her mother crying without any attempt to hide it — and Skylar blew them a kiss with the ease of a girl who had never once doubted she was loved out loud. *That's the other kind of rich,* Amara thought, and was glad, obscurely and completely, that Skylar had it, and that Skylar had shared her stage like it was nothing, like it was what stages were for.

Ask now, Amara had told him, in the corridor after. "You can ask now. That's the whole trick of being alive. You ask late, but you ask."

The host opened the envelope. The pause came, because the pause always comes; the band held its breath; the heartbeat music stopped.

Skylar's hand, between Amara's shoulder blades, pressed once. *Whatever it is, I'm here,* it said. Tariq's grip on her elbow tightened.

The winner of Voices of America, the host said, and turned the card around so the camera could read it before the hall could, "— is Amara Johnson."

News in the same category

‘If I Sing Well, Will You Give Me Food’ A Black Street Girl Asked at a Talent Show — And Then The Judge Laughed

30 Part