My Cousin Handcuffed Me at a Family Cookout—Then a Soldier Called Me General

Chapter 13

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"Emily was a child," I said. "She should never have had to carry the idea that her father left because he didn't love her."

Dad nodded without looking up.

"I know."

It was the same phrase everyone kept using.

Dad waited until the investigators' vehicles had left before he asked what would happen if the letter proved Thomas had been involved in something illegal. I said the evidence would have to be evaluated and that loving someone did not require pretending they were incapable of mistakes. He looked startled, as though he had expected me to defend Thomas without reservation.

We walked around the side of the house where the grass was cooler beneath the trees. Dad told me about the night of Thomas's second phone call. He had been standing in the kitchen with the lights off, watching rain slide down the glass. Thomas said he couldn't explain where he was, but he needed Dad to promise not to ask questions. Dad asked whether he was safe. Thomas said he was safer than he had been.

I asked whether Dad had ever considered recording the call or reporting it. He said he hadn't wanted to betray his brother. I asked whether he'd thought about Emily, who was waiting for an answer that might never come. Dad stared at the ground. He said he thought he was choosing the least harmful option.

The conversation left us both exhausted. Mom appeared on the porch and asked whether we wanted iced tea. For once, Dad said no and stayed outside with me. He asked about my work, not the ceremonies or the travel, but the people I was responsible for. I told him about a young lieutenant who had recently come to me worried about a mistake in a training report. We had corrected it together. Dad listened without interrupting.

He said Thomas used to tell him that I noticed things adults wished I wouldn't. I remembered being thirteen and asking why a county official could afford a new truck on a salary that seemed too small for it. Dad had told me to mind my business. Thomas had laughed and said I should keep asking.

For the first time, I wondered how different our family might have been if Dad had listened to his brother instead of asking him to be quiet.

I wondered whether knowing something after the damage was done could ever feel like enough.

* * *

On Wednesday evening, a retired county clerk named Margaret Ellis called the sheriff's office and asked to speak with someone about Thomas Carter.

She had seen a local news report about the reopened missing-person case. She remembered processing purchasing files for Pine Ridge Technical Services in 2008. At the time, she had noticed that several equipment deliveries were recorded as completed even though the county receiving office had no matching signatures.

Margaret had kept copies of her correspondence because she feared she would be blamed for the discrepancies. When she raised the issue, Captain Voss visited her office and told her the paperwork concerned a confidential law-enforcement project.

She believed him.

Years later, she found the copies while clearing out a filing cabinet at home.

Grant arranged an interview. I learned about it only after the fact, through the limited update the investigators could provide to the command.

Margaret's documents supported something Thomas had written in his notebooks: equipment had been billed through county accounts and transferred to locations that were not properly identified in the records. Some items were ordinary networking components. Others were specialized communications units.

The investigators still had to establish where the equipment went and who benefited. But the old allegations were no longer based only on Thomas's suspicions.

That evening, I called Emily.

"They found more records," I told her.

"Does that mean Dad was telling the truth?"

"About the contracts, it looks like his concerns had a basis."

"Then why did everybody act like he was unstable?"

I stared at the wall.

"Because it was easier for them than asking what he had found."

Emily breathed out slowly.

"I don't know whether that makes me feel better."

Margaret Ellis did not consider herself brave. When investigators thanked her for keeping the records, she told them she'd saved the papers because she was afraid someone would blame her for missing equipment. She had been raising two children alone in 2008 and couldn't afford to lose her job. She said she had tried to raise the discrepancies properly and stopped when a superior told her the matter was confidential.

The investigators took her statement and arranged to preserve the originals. They also asked whether she had discussed the records with Thomas. She remembered him coming to the receiving office twice, carrying a notebook with a torn green cover. He asked polite questions and wrote down the answers. He never told her he was investigating anyone. He said he was trying to make the numbers match.

News in the same category

My Cousin Handcuffed Me at a Family Cookout—Then a Soldier Called Me General

30 Part