Camille nodded. She said that distinction would matter if the case became public. We discussed whether I should make a statement to the family. I decided against it for the moment. The people who had watched the incident had enough information to understand it. I was not going to write an essay explaining why they should have intervened.
That night, Derek sent a short text saying he had spoken with his attorney and would give a formal account to investigators. I replied that it was the right step. He did not ask for forgiveness, and I did not offer it.
We ended the call there.
* * *
Rebecca requested a meeting with Sheriff Mercer the following week. Her attorney attended, and the conversation was recorded. She acknowledged taking Derek's card without permission. She said she had received an anonymous message warning that the old Thomas Carter documents would be released unless she brought the card to a specified location.
She claimed she had panicked and complied. The card was returned to her vehicle before the Memorial Day barbecue, along with the envelope containing Thomas's name.
Investigators could not immediately verify her account. There were no convenient camera angles, no perfect witness, and no confession from the person who sent the message. They were examining the communications and vehicle records through legal process.
Rebecca also admitted that she had approved purchasing documents in 2008 that she did not fully understand.
"I trusted Harold Voss," she told Mercer.
It was becoming a familiar sentence.
She said Voss had described the transactions as urgent security work that required discretion. When Thomas questioned the invoices, she had warned Voss that her brother-in-law was making trouble. Within days, Thomas disappeared.
For years, Rebecca had told herself the timing was a coincidence. She had told others that Thomas was unreliable and probably left voluntarily.
Her lawyer cautioned her not to speculate about responsibility. Rebecca stopped short of accusing Voss directly.
The next day, my mother called to tell me Rebecca wanted to speak to the family.
"Not at another barbecue," I said.
Mom gave a tired laugh.
Rebecca's admission changed the way I understood her behavior at the barbecue, but it didn't make it easier to accept. She had looked frightened before anyone mentioned the access card, and she had tried to stop Todd from recording. I wondered whether she had been protecting Derek, protecting herself, or trying to keep the past from surfacing. The investigators would have to establish what she knew. I could only describe what I had seen.
Mom told me Rebecca had been sleeping poorly. She wanted me to feel sorry for her. I did, in a limited way. Fear can make people behave badly, and I had seen enough frightened people to know that panic often produces foolish decisions. But Rebecca had also spent eighteen years repeating the claim that Thomas was unstable. That was not a moment of panic. It was a story she had chosen over and over.
Grandma Evelyn called and asked whether Rebecca would be arrested. I said I didn't know and that the investigators would make decisions based on evidence. Grandma sighed. She said the family had become a place where every phone call brought bad news. I reminded her that we had also learned Thomas might be alive. She was quiet, then admitted she didn't know whether to hope for that anymore.
I understood. If Thomas was alive, we would have to face the years he had stayed away. If he wasn't, we would have to confront the possibility that we'd been led toward a cruel false hope. Neither outcome promised a clean return to the family we'd imagined.
Later, I found an old voicemail from Rebecca on my phone. It was from the year I was promoted. She had called to congratulate me, then added a joke about how I must finally have a job that involved telling people what to do. I hadn't listened closely at the time. Now I heard how little she knew about the work behind the promotion. I deleted the voicemail, not because I wanted to erase her, but because I no longer wanted to keep evidence of every small insult.
I wanted to make room for what people chose to do next.
"No. I don't think any of us could stand that."
* * *
The letter from Thomas's attic box was addressed to my father, but its contents concerned all of us.
Investigators shared a copy after documenting it. Walter asked Emily and me to read it with him at the kitchen table.
Thomas had written it in November 2008, two days before he disappeared. He described the purchasing irregularities and his fear that someone in law enforcement was protecting the people involved. He said he had been offered a way to leave town temporarily while an investigation proceeded. He did not identify the person making the offer.