"Of course not."
The words were still ringing in my ears. Graham likes the idea of a perfect wife. And I know how to give him that. She had said it so easily, so calmly, as if honesty were a costume she could take off and put on again depending on who was in the room. And I understood, all at once, why she had been so careful all evening, why she had seated us at table twenty-nine, why she had laughed when Mother told her to put us at the back so we would not ruin the photos. She had not been afraid of us ruining the photos. She had been afraid of us ruining the performance.
Lily was shaking beside me. Not crying. Shaking, the way she shakes when she has been out in the cold too long. I wrapped both arms around her and held her against my side, and I could feel her small heart beating fast against my ribs. "It's okay," I whispered into her hair. "It's okay, baby. I'm here. I'm right here."
"But Mom," she whispered back, her voice so small I had to bend down to hear it. "Did I do the right thing? The groom looks so sad."
I looked up at the head table. Graham was still sitting there, his champagne glass still in his hand, staring at the black screen as if it might light up again and take it all back. Vanessa was standing beside him, her hand on his arm, talking fast, her mouth moving, her eyes wide. I could not hear what she was saying over the noise of the room, but I could see the shape of it. Denial. Explanation. Please. I had seen that face before, on the night Daniel left, when I had asked him where he was going and he had said it was nobody's fault.
"I don't know yet, sweetheart," I told Lily, because I would not lie to her, not tonight, not after everything. "But you told the truth. And the truth is never the wrong thing to tell, even when it hurts."
The lights were still down. Someone near the stage was calling for the lights, someone else was calling for security, and the DJ's voice came over the speakers, thin and panicked, asking everyone to please stay calm. But nobody was calm. The ballroom that had been so perfect an hour ago, all chandeliers and white flowers and champagne, had turned into something else entirely, a room full of people who had just watched a wedding come apart in front of them and did not know where to look.
Vanessa's voice rose above the noise then, sharp and high, and I heard her say Graham's name, and then I heard Graham's voice, low and steady, cutting through everything else in the room.
"How long?"
I watched Graham's hands as he stood there. They were shaking, just slightly, the way a person's hands shake when they are holding something very heavy and trying not to drop it. He kept them at his sides, and he did not reach for his glass, and he did not reach for her, and I understood that he was holding himself together by force of will alone. I had done the same thing once, standing in my own hallway, watching Daniel pack a suitcase, holding myself together because Lily was asleep upstairs and someone had to be the steady one. I knew exactly how much it cost him to stand there and not fall apart. And I wished, absurdly and fiercely, that I could go to him and tell him it would be all right, that the worst part was almost over, that the truth, once it was out, could not hurt him any more than the lie already had.
"How long?"
Graham's voice was not loud, but it carried. It carried the way a voice carries in a church, and the whole room seemed to lean toward it. He was standing now. I had not seen him stand. One moment he was sitting at the head table with his champagne going warm in his hand, and the next he was on his feet, facing my sister, and the ballroom had gone quiet again, the way a room goes quiet when everyone knows they are about to hear something they cannot unhear.
Vanessa's hand was still on his arm. She was still talking, still smiling, but the smile had gone wrong at the edges, the way a photograph goes wrong when the light is too harsh. "Graham, please," she said. "Please, not here. Not in front of everyone. Let me explain. It's not what it looked like. It was a long time ago. It was over before we even—"