Three hundred guests. I counted the tables twice when we first sat down, because counting was something I could do while my hands were shaking. Thirty tables of ten, each one dressed in cream linen and white flowers, each one glowing under the crystal. The string quartet played near the windows. Waiters in white gloves moved between the tables with trays of champagne, and the air smelled of lilies and candle wax and money.
Vanessa was at the head table, of course. She had always known how to be the center of a room. Her ivory lace dress caught the light every time she moved, and the diamonds at her neck threw small bright sparks across the tablecloth. Graham Ellison sat beside her, tall and handsome in his black tuxedo, his hand resting over hers, and he looked at her the way men in love stories look at the woman they are about to marry — like she was the only real thing in the room.
Graham was a successful real estate attorney. Everyone said so. He had money, and connections, and a beautiful house, and he had chosen my little sister, and for the past year my mother had spoken about the wedding the way other people speak about miracles. Vanessa had found a good man. Vanessa had done it right. Vanessa had everything.
My mother had told me about Graham the way she told me about everything Vanessa did — with a shine in her voice that she had never once used for me. She told me about his house, and his firm, and the way he had proposed, and the apartment Vanessa now lived in, spacious and bright, overlooking Newport Harbor, decorated in cream and gold and white, like a page torn out of a magazine. She told me these things on the phone, in the same tone she had used when we were girls and Vanessa won a prize, or Vanessa was chosen for the lead in the school play, or Vanessa came home with a boy my mother approved of. The tone that said: look at your sister. Look at what a daughter can be.
I had never envied Vanessa's life. I want to be honest about that, because it matters. I did not want the harbor apartment, or the diamonds, or the man with the connections. I wanted my small apartment with the star-yellow sheets, and my daughter's laugh in the mornings, and the quiet of grading papers at a kitchen table while Lily did her homework across from me. I wanted the life I had built with my own two hands, out of nothing, after Daniel left. But sitting there at table twenty-nine, watching my sister glow under the chandeliers while my mother beamed at her from across the room, I felt the old ache anyway — not envy, but the weariness of a woman who has spent her whole life being measured against someone else, and always coming up short in the eyes of the only person whose opinion had ever mattered.
The flowers on the head table were white roses, dozens of them, their petals open and perfect. The candlelight caught the crystal glasses and threw small rainbows onto the linen. It was beautiful. It was the most beautiful room I had ever sat in. And I had never felt further from home.
I sat at table twenty-nine with my daughter, in a navy dress I had bought seven years ago for a school fundraiser, back when Daniel and I were still married and I still believed that a dress could make me belong somewhere. The seam under the armpit had been mended twice. I had ironed it flat that morning, pressing the fabric until my hands ached, because I wanted it to look new even though it was not.
Lily wore a pale yellow top I had found at a thrift store, soft from many washings, and a white skirt that she had twirled in three times in front of the mirror. She looked beautiful. She looked like the best thing I had ever made, and I had spent the whole drive here reminding myself that we were here because Vanessa was my sister, and because family shows up, and because my daughter deserved to see a wedding, even a wedding where we did not belong.
The head table was far away, half hidden behind the pillar beside our table. Our table was the only one with no flowers. I noticed it the moment we sat down, the bare cream linen where a vase should have been, and I told myself it did not matter. I told myself a lot of things that day.
Six hours earlier, the apartment was quiet except for the sound of the iron hissing and Lily humming in her bedroom.
Our apartment is small — two bedrooms, one bathroom, a kitchen where the faucet drips if you do not turn it just right. It is the apartment Daniel left three years ago, and it is the apartment where Lily and I have built our whole life since: her bed with the star-yellow sheets, the stuffed bunny she has slept with since she was three, the kitchen table where I grade papers until midnight and where she does her homework in the afternoons. It is not much. It is ours.