I did not sleep well that night. Every time I drifted off I saw the stone in the bag on the counter, the white flakes bright against the plastic, and I kept thinking about the way Helen had stood at her mailbox the week before, watching my roof, her face closed like a door. At two in the morning I got up and stood at the kitchen counter in the dark, looking at the bag, and I had the absurd urge to throw the stone away — to un-find it, to go back to not knowing. Evidence doesn't work that way, I told myself. You don't get to undiscover things. But I stood there a long time anyway, the tile cold under my bare feet, wishing I were the kind of person who could.
In the morning I walked my property line the way I had started doing every few days, checking for anything else that did not belong. The desert light was still low and kind, and the gravel crunched under my shoes. I found three more stones in the side yard between my house and Helen's, pale river rocks scattered in the gravel where no landscaping bed had ever been — one half-buried, two sitting on top like they'd been dropped from above. I crouched down and looked at the roofline, then at the stones, then at Helen's fence, and the trajectory drew itself in my mind without my permission: thrown upward from her side, arcing over, landing short. None of them had paint on them. But they were the same size as the one in my gutter, and the same kind of rock, and they had not been there when I raked that gravel in March.
I bagged them too, separately, and dated the bags with a marker. I was a science teacher. I believed in samples and labels and chains of evidence, and I was building a case the way I would have taught my students to build one: quietly, methodically, and without drawing conclusions until the data forced them. I lined the three bags up on the counter next to the first one, and they looked absurd there — four zip-top bags of ordinary rocks, like a child's collection — except that each one was a small, silent accusation, and I was the only one who knew it.
The data was already leaning, though, and I could feel it leaning the way you feel a ladder starting to tip. I just did not want to be the one to say where it was leaning toward.
Chapter 11: The Roofer's Visit
The roofer came on a Tuesday. His name was on the side of his truck in peeling letters, and he was the third contractor I had called, because the first two had quoted me over the phone without looking at anything, and I had decided that I needed someone who would actually climb up there.
He was a man in his fifties with sun-leathered skin and a measuring tape clipped to his belt, and he spent twenty minutes on my roof with a camera, moving carefully between the rows of panels the way you move through a place that is not yours. When he came down, he wiped his face with a bandana and said, "You want the repair quote, or you want what I actually think?"
"Both," I said. "In that order."
"The quote is easy," he said. "Five panels, replacement and rewiring, and I'll want to pull the rails and check every bolt before I sign off on it. That's the expensive part of the truth I just found up there." He looked at me. "Now here's what I actually think. Somebody's been hitting your array. Not with weather. With rocks, probably. And here's the part your insurance is going to care about — the mounting bolts on two of those rails are loose in a way I don't see from wind. That's rocking. Repeated rocking. Like the rail's been vibrated loose over time by impacts."
"Thrown stones," I said.
He shrugged. "Thrown stones, kicked soccer balls, a kid with a slingshot — I can't tell you the hand, ma'am. I can tell you the physics. Something's been hitting the lower edge of your array, over and over, for weeks. And whoever it is, they're aiming at the panels, not the roof. Your shingles are fine. Your flashing is fine. It's the glass that's taking it."
I asked him to put that in writing. He looked at me for a moment, then nodded, and wrote it on the back of his quote sheet in block letters: MOUNTING BOLTS LOOSENED BY REPEATED IMPACT — CONSISTENT WITH THROWN OBJECTS. He signed it and dated it.
"You're building a file," he said. It wasn't a question.
"I'm a teacher," I said. "I like documentation." I hesitated, then added, "And I think I'm going to need it."
He studied me for a moment, and whatever he saw in my face made him nod slowly. "Then document everything," he said. "Dates, times, photos. The people who get believed are the people with paper." He tapped the quote sheet. "This is paper. Keep it somewhere safe."