My Neighbor Set My Mailbox on Fire — But I Already Knew Exactly Why She Did It

Chapter 2

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Our neighborhood association was small and unassuming. It collected annual fees for minor landscaping, snow removal, and clubhouse maintenance. For years, I barely gave it a second thought. Then, Colleen Avery became treasurer.

Colleen lived two houses down in a yellow home with dark green shutters. She was fifty-eight, widowed, incredibly organized, and endlessly helpful. She was the cornerstone of the community:

  • The Caretaker: She helped older homeowners fill out rebate applications and carried tax forms for those who couldn't drive.

  • The Confidante: She remembered birthdays, hospitalizations, and family milestones.

  • The Collector: She collected annual fees in person from residents who disliked online payments.

Because of this, people trusted her with account numbers, copies of identification, and personal documents. She always reassured us with the same gentle phrase:

"We’re neighbors. We take care of one another."

I trusted her too. Years earlier, she notarized a residency form for my mortgage refinance. Later, she helped me complete an insurance survey after a hailstorm. The form asked for extensive details—birth dates, our mortgage company, and the last four digits of my Social Security number. When I questioned it, she just smiled and said the insurer required it for "owner verification."

News in the same category

My Neighbor Set My Mailbox on Fire — But I Already Knew Exactly Why She Did It

7 Part