My Neighbor Set My Mailbox on Fire — But I Already Knew Exactly Why She Did It

Chapter 6

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Colleen stared at me, her mask finally slipping. "You set me up."

"No," I answered. "You decided fire was easier than answering questions."

As the postal inspectors sifted through the ashes, they found something chilling. Beneath the burned decoy envelope were fragments of other people's mail—Evelyn’s, Howard’s, and addresses from six different streets.

Colleen had planted stolen mail in my mailbox before setting the fire. Her backup plan was diabolical: if the police investigated, they would find stolen neighborhood mail in my burned box, framing me as the mastermind of the identity theft ring.

By noon, investigators executed a warrant on the storage unit registered to Colleen’s brother. Inside, they found a fraudster's goldmine: blank loan applications, copied IDs, forged signatures, and twenty-seven boxes of HOA records.

They also found a map of the neighborhood with photographs of mailboxes marked by colored stickers:

  • Blue: Homeowner has strong credit.

  • Yellow: Property has little or no mortgage debt.

  • Red: Resident is elderly, recently widowed, or socially isolated.

My mailbox on the map had been marked Black.

When Felicia asked Colleen what black meant in the interrogation room, she refused to answer.

The answer was found inside a locked cash box at the back of the storage unit. Inside was a master ledger detailing fraudulent lines of credit. At the very bottom was a list of eleven targeted homes under a heading written in Colleen's pristine handwriting.

News in the same category

My Neighbor Set My Mailbox on Fire — But I Already Knew Exactly Why She Did It

7 Part