Nurse Stops a Doctor at the Hospital Entrance—Then Everyone Learns Who He Really Is

Chapter 17

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"You had a badge this morning, Doctor," she said. "And a dying man. The door could see both."

"And if I'd had neither?"

"I would have kept you eleven minutes," she said, "and called Howard Lin, and lived with it. The rule can't know your name, Dr. Sheikh. That's not cruelty. That's the only version of it that's worth a patient's trust." She considered him, this man who had asked for her door instead of her head, and added the thing she had been composing since the trustee's chair: "It has to work exactly the same for the chief in a hurry and the trustee in a temper. Otherwise it isn't a door. It's a mirror — it just shows people their own rank coming back at them. I kept a mirror for six weeks. I'd rather keep a door."

Getting the hearing into existence took three weeks, and the three weeks taught Imran Sheikh more about his hospital than the eleven minutes had, because a building reveals itself not in its emergencies but in its scheduling. The medical-staff meeting was a monthly fixture, ordinarily attended by the obliged and the ambitious, fed with sandwiches, and forgotten by the following Tuesday. To make it the vessel for the review's findings required the board's consent, the bylaws' blessing, and the neutralization of Dr. Harold Crane's counterattack, which arrived, as his things always arrived, beautifully drafted and one day early: a memorandum to the board asserting that peer-review materials were confidential under state law and the medical staff bylaws, that their presentation to a general assembly would expose the hospital to litigation by every physician named or identifiable, and that the quality committee — his committee — stood ready to receive the review's concerns in camera and act upon them with discretion.

Lindgren read the memorandum twice in Sheikh's presence and then did a thing he had not expected and would not forget: she laughed, once, without mirth, like a woman recognizing a move in a game she had finally decided to stop playing. "In camera," she said. "Discretion. Mr. Chairman, your committee received these concerns in camera in 2016, and exercised its discretion, and the discretion is why we're here." She approved the meeting, expanded: the full medical staff, the board invited, nursing leadership invited — the inclusion of nursing being Sheikh's amendment and Fran Deluca's routing slips being its unanswerable argument, since the memos were nursing's documents and had been addressed, nine years ago, to everyone. The data would be presented in aggregate, by department and disposition, the way Hannah had built it; individual files would be referenced by their record language, not prosecuted by name, except where a physician chose to speak of his own. It was a lawyer-tested architecture, and Crane, reading the decision, sent back one line through his assistant: he noted the ruling, and requested the chair's privilege of response. The privilege was granted. A room, Sheikh thought, that lets the accused answer is a room that can be believed when it convicts; he had sat through enough tribunals, of enough kinds, to know that fairness is not the enemy of reckoning but its only durable form.

Fran Deluca arrived on a Thursday, on a ticket purchased by the hospital and upgraded, at her own expense and over the airline's confusion, to a seat with room for her knees. Claudia met her at the gate with a sign she had lettered herself, out of a family sense of occasion: THE MEMO, it said, and Fran, coming up the jetway in a navy suit with her good shoes on, read it and announced to the entire arrivals hall, in the voice that had trained a third of a hospital, "Subtlety was always her father's side." She had not been inside Aldercrest in nine years. She insisted on entering through the main atrium, not the clinic door Claudia had planned, and she walked it slowly, on her daughter's arm — past the coffee cart, past the donor wall, past the new directory with its backlit departments — and twice, nurses of a certain age stopped dead in the traffic of the lobby and said her name like a diagnosis confirmed, and one of them, a charge nurse with silver in her hair, came out from behind the information desk and embraced her without a word of greeting first, the way you embrace a person returned from a country you expected never to hear from again.

"They gave me a cake," Fran told her, patting her back. "Did you get cake? Nobody ever gets cake for being right early. They get cake for leaving."

News in the same category

Nurse Stops a Doctor at the Hospital Entrance—Then Everyone Learns Who He Really Is

30 Part