Nurse Stops a Doctor at the Hospital Entrance—Then Everyone Learns Who He Really Is

Chapter 19

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

They came the way weather comes to a coast — first the obliged, then the curious, then everyone who had understood, all at once, that history was about to be weather too. By six o'clock the auditorium held its four hundred chairs and perhaps fifty standing along the back wall: surgeons in scrubs and surgeons in suits, the board in a reserved row like a jury that had dressed for it, nurses filling the side aisles because nursing had been invited and nursing, when invited, attends. Petra sat with Deirdre Fenn near the aisle, her notebook closed in her lap like a sleeping animal. Hannah Weiss sat in the third row with her laptop and the particular pallor of a woman who has checked her figures eleven times and would have given a year of her life for a twelfth check to find something, anything, wrong with them. At the front, at a plain table, sat Andrea Lindgren and Imran Sheikh, and between them, placed with ceremony by a facilities orderly who had been given the specification twice, an empty chair with arms.

Lindgren opened without a speech. "This is a meeting of the medical staff," she said, "expanded by invitation of the board, to receive the report of the review I commissioned in September of the entrance standard and the matters the entrance standard brought to light. The data will be shown in aggregate. Dr. Sheikh will frame the review. Ms. Weiss will present. Dr. Crane has the chair's privilege of response. And we will hear a witness the hospital should have heard nine years ago." She sat down. It was the shortest thing she had ever said in that room and everyone knew it.

Sheikh stood. He had worn, at last, a suit — the building noted it; the sweater had become such an emblem that its absence felt like a statement, which it was, though not the one people assumed: he had worn it because testimony is formal even when the witness stand is a folding table. "Nine weeks ago," he said, "I stood in the lobby of this hospital for eleven minutes while a patient of mine was bleeding, because a nurse at the staff door did her job as this hospital had taught it to her, and because I could not prove to her satisfaction that I deserved to pass. I want to begin where the building would prefer I didn't. She was right to stop the man she saw. Sixty pages of log, reviewed by my office, say that the door she kept stopped the unknown and the unimportant with perfect fidelity, and waved through the known and the suited with perfect courtesy, and that she is not the only keeper it has ever had, and that I am not the only man it has ever misread. It misread me as a threat. It has spent years misreading trustees as safe. Eleven minutes is my whole injury, and I am standing here healed of it, and the patient lived. If this meeting were about the door, it would be a short meeting and a smaller room."

He let the silence do the arithmetic. "But the door was a diagnosis. The disease is older and it sits in better chairs. For nine years, this hospital's peer-review process — the conscience by which we judge our own worst moments — has disposed of complaints by a standard I will now ask Ms. Weiss to show you, because it cannot be summarized honestly, only shown. I will say one thing first, as the chief who received this data and chose to bring it into this room rather than to the four people who could have buried it in an afternoon. Nothing you are about to see is an accusation against any individual in the aggregate slides. It is a picture of us, taken from an unflattering side, by our own record, kept by our own hands. What we do about having seen it is the only agenda item."

Hannah stood, and the first slide went up, and four hundred people looked at the hospital's conscience rendered as columns. She spoke without notes and almost without inflection, which was the correct music for it: the numbers, she understood, were their own rhetoric, and ornament would only give the room somewhere else to look. Thirty-nine dispositions, nine years, arranged by the seniority of the physician complained of and the origin of his training. Twenty-three complaints against surgeons of twenty years' standing or more — the names, though she did not say them, hung in the room like the smell of rain. Twenty-three complaints. Dispositions: no action, twenty-three times, in the record's own vocabulary — closed, reviewed, education provided, no concerns, and once, for a retained sponge that the scrub team had counted aloud in the record, systems learning opportunity, file closed.

Then the second column, and the room made a sound that was not quite a sound: sixteen complaints against staff in their first decade, against the internationally trained, against the new. Fourteen formal actions. Proctoring. Privilege restrictions. A reprimand template so reused that Hannah, advancing the slide, showed the room its own boilerplate — the same sentences, file after file, the hospital's conscience speaking in a form letter to the powerless and in a lullaby to the powerful. She showed the reviewing initials in aggregate, a forest of two letters. She showed the door's data last — 5:02, waved through; 5:41, held — because she had built the presentation with a dramatist's instinct she would have denied possessing: the committee and the door, the two speeds of the building, side by side on one screen.

News in the same category

Nurse Stops a Doctor at the Hospital Entrance—Then Everyone Learns Who He Really Is

30 Part