Officer Arrested a Quiet Black Man Beside His Own Car — Then FBI Agents Walked Into the Hearing

Chapter 24

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Higgins did not object to that statement. He wrote something on his pad, underlined it twice, and then looked at Puit. Puit's hands had moved, almost imperceptibly, from flat on the pad to clasped together, his thumbs pressed against each other. He did not look at Higgins. He looked at the folders on Renee's table, as if counting them.

Renee closed the audio folder and opened the next one, which was thinner. "Item Five," she said. "A timeline, prepared by the Bureau for the panel's convenience, consolidating Items One through Four into a single chronological sequence. It adds no new fact. It simply places the log entries, the video times, and the dispatch times side by side, so the panel can see alignment. I offer it as a demonstrative aid, not as independent evidence, and the defense may challenge any entry on it by reference to the underlying item."

She placed the timeline on the overhead projector, and the room could see it at once: a simple list, with times on the left and sources on the right. 18:42, assignment log. 19:05, arrival log. 19:12, federal footage, sedan parks in space 14. 19:15, mall video, sedan in space 14. 19:31, waiting log. 19:58, status log, no change. 20:02 to 20:08, cruiser circling and stopping, both videos. 20:09 to 20:10, cuffing, both videos. 20:14, disruption log. 20:22, contact lost log. 20:41, transport log. The alignment was, on its face, unforced. The times did not need to be stretched to meet each other. They met on their own, within a minute or two, across three separate systems.

"Captain," Higgins said, standing again, "the defense objects to the timeline as cumulative and as argumentative in its selection. It selects only the entries that help the Bureau and omits everything else that might have been in the logs."

Chen considered that. "Mr. Higgins, the timeline is received as a demonstrative aid only, and I will note that it is not independent evidence. If there are entries in the underlying logs that you contend have been omitted and that are relevant, you may identify them in cross-examination or in your own presentation, and the panel will consider them. The Bureau has provided the underlying logs, not only the timeline, so the defense is not limited to the aid. Objection overruled as to receipt as an aid, sustained as to any claim that the timeline itself proves a fact beyond its sources."

Renee nodded. "Thank you, Captain. That completes the Bureau's documentary presentation, subject to the panel's questions and the defense's cross-examination. I have one further item, which is not a document but a statement of availability: the Bureau will make the original footage and the original logs available for inspection by the panel and by the defense under safeguards, as I stated earlier, and will provide a custodian if the panel requires one. The Bureau does not ask the panel to take any of this on faith. It asks the panel to inspect, if it wishes, and to weigh."

Chen looked at Higgins. "Mr. Higgins, do you wish to cross-examine Special Agent Holloway at this time on the items presented, or do you wish to reserve cross-examination until after the county's witnesses?"

Higgins glanced at his notes, then at Puit, then back at Chen. "Captain, the defense will reserve detailed cross-examination until the county's witnesses have been heard, but I wish to ask two brief questions now, for the record, about the limits of the disclosure."

"Proceed," Chen said.

"Special Agent Holloway," Higgins said, his voice careful now, "is it correct that the Bureau has not disclosed the full contents of Agent Ellery's assignment, and that the panel therefore cannot know what he was waiting to do, beyond the fact that he was waiting?"

"That is correct," Renee said. "The panel knows he was on assignment, in that location, at those times, waiting. The panel does not know, from this disclosure, the operational detail, and the Bureau asks the panel not to need it."

"And is it correct," Higgins continued, "that the Bureau has not disclosed any communication between Agent Ellery and the person he was waiting to meet?"

"That is correct," Renee said. "No such communication is disclosed, and none is offered. The panel has only the fact that a contact was scheduled, that it was disrupted by the patrol approach, and that contact was then lost. The person concerned slipped away when patrol arrived, as the record already states. No further detail is provided."

Higgins sat down, apparently satisfied that he had established the limits on the record, even if he had not undermined the items themselves. He whispered something to Puit again, and Puit nodded, his expression still guarded, his hands still clasped.

News in the same category

Officer Arrested a Quiet Black Man Beside His Own Car — Then FBI Agents Walked Into the Hearing

45 Part