Officer Arrested a Quiet Black Man Beside His Own Car — Then FBI Agents Walked Into the Hearing

Chapter 29

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Higgins asked him to walk the room through March 17, in his own words, without interruption. Puit nodded, and for a moment he looked not at Higgins but at a point just past him, as if he were seeing the lot again. He said he had been on routine patrol just after seven in the evening when he noticed a sedan parked in Zone D, in a row that was mostly empty. The lot was dark, he said. The light was flickering. There was a man beside the car, standing close to the driver's side door, after hours, in a part of the lot where no one had any business being. He said he had approached because that was what patrol did: you checked on a person in a dark lot, you asked what they were doing, you made sure nothing was being taken. He said the man had been evasive. He had not answered directly. He had kept his hands where Puit could not see them clearly, and when Puit asked for identification, the man had not produced it. Puit said he had made a judgment call. Based on his experience, based on the darkness, based on the man's refusal to identify himself, he had believed a burglary was imminent, or in progress, and he had detained the man and then arrested him. He said he had followed procedure as he understood it. He said he had written his report that night, while the details were fresh, and that he believed at the time that his report was accurate.

Higgins let the last sentence sit. Then he asked, gently, whether Puit had any doubt, that night, that he was doing the right thing. Puit said no. He said he had believed he was preventing a crime. He said he would rather be questioned for stopping someone than explain later why he had driven past a burglary in progress. That was the line Higgins had clearly wanted, and Puit delivered it without emphasis, which made it sound less like a slogan and more like a working rule he had actually lived by.

Chen waited until Higgins had finished his direct examination before she spoke. She did not raise her voice. She opened her folder to a page she had already marked, and she began not with an accusation but with a correction, delivered as a matter of record. She said the hearing had already established, through mall records and through the federal footage, that the Riverside Mall had not closed at seven on March 17. The mall had remained open until nine. The bakery on the east concourse had still been serving. The pharmacy's neon sign had still been lit, visible from Zone D. The lot had not been empty in the sense Puit's report suggested. It had been thinning, yes, but cars had still been coming and going, and the footage showed foot traffic near the east entrance until well after eight. She asked Puit whether he disputed those facts.

Puit hesitated. It was the first hesitation in his testimony, and it was small, a pause rather than a retreat. He said he had not meant that the entire mall was closed. He had meant that Zone D itself was quiet, that the shops nearest that lot had already shut their doors, that the far lot felt after hours even if the building technically had not closed. Chen repeated his words back to him, quietly, without sarcasm: felt after hours. She asked whether his report had said felt after hours, or whether it had said after hours, as a fact. Puit looked down at his own hands. He said his report had said after hours. He said he had meant it in the sense he had just described. Chen did not argue the point. She simply noted, for the record, that the report's wording and the witness's present explanation were not the same, and she moved on.

She turned to the light. The flickering light over the third row. Puit had described it as a central part of why the scene had looked suspicious: a man in a dark lot, under a failing light. Chen asked whether Puit had checked, that night or since, whether the light had actually been flickering on March 17, or whether it had been out entirely, or working. Puit said he had not checked the maintenance log. He said he had seen it flicker on other nights, and he had assumed it was flickering that night. Chen asked whether assumption was a proper basis for a report that would later be used to justify an arrest. Puit said he understood the question, and that in hindsight he should have been more precise. The phrase in hindsight appeared for the first time, and it would appear again, each time a little more carefully placed.

Chen moved to the sedan. She asked Puit what he had known about the car before he approached it. Puit said he had run the plate, or believed he had, and that nothing had come back that changed his assessment. Chen asked him to be specific: had he run the plate before the stop, or after the arrest, or not at all. Puit said he had run it after the arrest, during booking, as part of the routine. He admitted, when pressed, that he had not run it before approaching the man. Chen asked whether he had known, before the arrest, that the sedan was registered, that it was not reported stolen, that it belonged to no one with a burglary history. Puit said he had not known those things at the time. Chen noted that the federal logs, admitted earlier, showed the sedan's registration clearly, and that the footage showed no tool, no pry bar, no bag, no second person, nothing in the man's hands except a phone. She asked Puit whether he had seen any tool that night. Puit said no. She asked whether he had seen the man attempt to enter any vehicle other than his own, or any store, or any locked door. Puit said no. She asked whether he had seen the man touch any car other than the sedan. Puit said no.

News in the same category

Officer Arrested a Quiet Black Man Beside His Own Car — Then FBI Agents Walked Into the Hearing

45 Part