The Daybreak Diner opened at five-thirty, but Louise Harrington had never in eleven years arrived later than five, because the first hour of a diner belonged to nobody but the people who worked in it, and she liked it that way. She liked the cold key in the lock and the alarm's brief complaint. She liked the smell the place held overnight — yesterday's coffee sealed into the wood of the counter, grease gone quiet in the hood, the faint sweet ghost of other people's breakfasts — and the way it gave itself up, layer by layer, as the grills came on. She liked flipping the sign in the window from CLOSED to OPEN with the street still dark and empty, as if she were letting the day into Youngstown one Federal Street at a time.
Lou was thirty-nine years old that October, and she had been a waitress at the Daybreak since she was twenty-eight, which meant the job had outlasted her marriage, her mother's living years, two cars, and every plan she had made at twenty-five with a straight face. She wore her hair pinned up under a net though Sal had stopped requiring nets sometime in 2003. She kept a pencil behind her ear and another in her apron, because a waitress with one pencil was a waitress about to borrow. Her order pad lived in the left pocket. Her tips lived in the right until they didn't. She knew the regulars the way a lighthouse knows ships — not by their cargo, just by their lights and their schedules — and she could tell you, for any man who came through the door before seven, what he would order, how he took his coffee, whether his wife was living, and whether today was a talking day or a leave-him-alone day, and she would never have told you any of it, because that was the whole of the profession as she understood it: to know everything and serve it with the eggs.
Sal Benedetti owned the Daybreak and cooked in it, which in his opinion were the same job done at two temperatures. He was fifty-eight, a widower, a man built like a fireplug who had come up from a mill family on the east side and bought the diner in 1989 with money nobody in his family had ever seen at one time before. He stood at the grill from five-thirty until two and ruled the kitchen by a code of perhaps nine laws, all unwritten, beginning with Waste nothing and ending with The coffee is never too old for a cop. He and Lou had not had a serious argument in eleven years, not because they agreed, but because each of them had long ago worked out which of the other's opinions were weather and which were climate, and had stopped dressing for the weather.
That October, Youngstown was in one of its long gray moods. The mills were a memory with real estate. The leaves came down early and the rain took them into the gutters, and Federal Street at six in the morning was a row of dark storefronts and lit windows, the diner one of the lit ones, pouring its yellow light out onto the wet sidewalk in a shape like a held door. The morning trade was what it had been for years: road crews and nurses and county men, old Tony Papas who read the newspaper front to back and then back to front, a pair of sheriff's deputies on Tuesdays, truckers off the interstate who found the place by the oldest navigation there is, which is hunger and a lit window. Lou worked the counter and the four booths along the wall. The register was older than she was. Under the register, on the low shelf where the takeout bags lived, sat a shoebox.
The shoebox was a Florsheim box, size eleven, its lid taped once at the corner where it had split. It had been there longer than the takeout bags, longer than the current menus. Nobody who came into the Daybreak had ever seen inside it, because there was never a reason to open it in front of anybody, and Lou was not a woman who explained her furniture. If you had asked Sal about it — and in eleven years, to his credit, he had asked exactly once — he would have told you what she told him: Tabs. What kind of tabs, Lou. The kind that aren't finished yet. He had nodded and gone back to his grill, because Sal Benedetti understood that in a diner, as in a marriage, some shelves are load-bearing precisely because nobody leans on them.