Police Chief’s Son Dragged a Black Man Out of a Diner — Unaware He Was the New Mayor

Chapter 11

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The stop happened on a Tuesday in October, on Delancey where the streetlights had been out for three weeks and nobody at Public Works had gotten around to the work order. Darius Cole was nineteen, a sophomore at the community college, driving his mother's dented Corolla home from a night shift stocking shelves at the FoodTown on Route 9. He had the radio low and his registration in the glove box and both hands at ten and two because his mother had taught him that a long time ago, before he'd ever needed the lesson. The cruiser came up behind him fast, no lights at first, just the high beams filling his mirror, and then the bar lit up red and blue and bounced off the empty storefronts. Darius pulled into the lot of the closed laundromat and killed the engine and put his hands on the dash where they could be seen. He had not been speeding. He knew that because he'd checked the needle the way you check your pulse when you're already scared.

Tyler Voss walked up with his flashlight already on, though the car was lit well enough by the cruiser's takedowns, and tapped the glass with the butt of it, twice, hard enough to leave a mark Darius would find the next morning. License and registration, Tyler said, and Darius said yes sir and moved slowly, narrating each motion the way he'd been taught at the kitchen table, reaching for the glove box, reaching for his wallet, and Tyler's light followed his hands like it was waiting for a reason. You know why I stopped you, Tyler said. Darius said no sir, I don't. Your plate light's out, Tyler said, and swept the beam across the back of the Corolla. Darius didn't look. He knew the plate light worked because his mother had him check it every Sunday along with the tires. You been drinking tonight, Tyler said. No sir. You sure about that. Yes sir. Step out of the car.

Darius stepped out into the wind coming off the harbor and the cruiser's spotlight held him there, pinned against the Corolla's door. Tyler told him to put his hands on the roof and Darius did. Tyler's hands moved fast and rough, pockets turned out, waistband, shoes, and then the car: glove box dumped onto the passenger seat, his backpack unzipped and shaken, textbooks slid across the seat, a sandwich bag of change from the FoodTown register drawer — his tips, five dollars and change — held up to the light like it was something else. Where'd this come from, Tyler said. It's my tips, Darius said, from work. Tyler set the bag on the Corolla's trunk and went back to the car and came out with the spare tire wrench and popped the trunk and lifted the mat and ran his hand around the wheel well. He found nothing because there was nothing to find. He stood in the lot with the wrench in his hand and looked at Darius for a long moment, and then he walked the wrench over to the Corolla's left taillight and, with the flat of it, struck the housing once, cracking the red plastic so that a shard fell and chimed on the asphalt. Now your taillight's out too, he said. Get it fixed. He wrote no ticket. He got in his cruiser and left Darius standing there in the spotlight's afterglow with his backpack spilled and his hands shaking too hard to zip it.

Angela Cole believed in paperwork the way some people believe in prayer. She worked the early shift at the hospital laundry and she kept a folder in her kitchen drawer with Darius's birth certificate and his vaccination record and his student loan papers, and into that folder the next morning went the Polaroid of the broken taillight and the receipt for the replacement housing and a written account of everything Darius had told her, dated and signed. She went to the police station on her lunch break with Darius beside her, and she asked for a complaint form, and the desk officer slid it across the counter without looking up, and she filled it out in her careful block letters: her son's name, the date, the time, the badge number Darius had memorized from the cruiser's door. She described the search. She described the taillight. She wrote, at the bottom, "My son was treated like a criminal for driving home from work." She handed it back and the officer stamped it and gave her a copy and she put the copy in the folder.

The complaint entered the system as IA File 14-229. It sat for eleven days. On the twelfth day it was assigned to Internal Affairs, and on the thirteenth day Lieutenant Dennis Hargrove picked it up on his way to the coffee machine and carried it into his office and read it standing up. Hargrove had been IA for nine years. He had a daughter in braces and a mortgage and a golf game with the chief every other Sunday at the municipal course, and he understood his job the way a man understands a current: you did not fight it, you moved with it, and the current in Bellwether flowed one way. He called Sergeant Paul Reilly in Patrol, who had been Tyler's field training officer two years back and still took the kid's calls. Hargrove read Angela Cole's words aloud over the phone. There was a silence. Then Reilly said, "I'll talk to him." Hargrove said, "Talk to him about what the report says." That was the whole conversation. The next morning Reilly submitted a memo to IA: the stop had been for an inoperable plate lamp, observed prior to the stop; the search of the vehicle had been a lawful inventory-adjacent protective sweep conducted with the driver's consent; no contraband was recovered; no force was used; the taillight damage was noted as pre-existing in the officer's account and was not observed by the complainant at the time of the stop. Reilly had not been there. He had not spoken to Darius Cole. He had spoken to Tyler for six minutes in the parking lot behind the precinct, and Tyler had said the kid was mouthy, and Reilly had said, "Write me what I need," and Tyler had written it.

Angela Cole received the disposition letter forty-one days after she filed. It was one paragraph. "The Internal Affairs Division has completed its investigation of your complaint (IA 14-229). The evidence does not support a finding of misconduct. The stop was lawful, the search was consensual, and the alleged property damage is unsubstantiated. This case is closed." No signature she recognized. A stamp. She read it three times at the kitchen table while Darius sat across from her doing homework, and then she folded it and put it in the folder with everything else, because that was what she did with important papers. Darius never told her about the wrench. He told her years later, after he'd transferred to the state university and was studying criminal justice, and by then the folder was in a box in her closet and the taillight had been fixed for years and the only thing left of that Tuesday was the way Darius still checked his plate light every Sunday, out of habit, out of something deeper than habit.

News in the same category

Police Chief’s Son Dragged a Black Man Out of a Diner — Unaware He Was the New Mayor

30 Part