Police Chief’s Son Dragged a Black Man Out of a Diner — Unaware He Was the New Mayor

Chapter 12

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The second one happened on a Friday in May, at the Copper Line, the music venue down on the waterfront where the bands played too loud and the beer was cheap and the bouncer at the door was a man named Marcus Doyle who had played two years of junior college football and had a scar through his left eyebrow from a bottle in Cleveland. Tyler Voss came in around eleven with four friends, already drunk, already loud, and Doyle carded the group at the rope the way he carded everyone, and Tyler leaned in and said, "You know who my father is," and Doyle said, "I don't care if your father's the pope," and waved them in anyway because the line was long and the night was young and Doyle had learned that the path of least resistance was usually the right one.

By one in the morning Tyler was on the edge of the stage shouting lyrics into the guitarist's face, and the guitarist shoved him back, and Tyler swung, and missed, and swung again and caught Doyle's shoulder as Doyle came in to pull him off. Doyle had thrown out drunks for six years. He knew the holds. He had Tyler's arm twisted up behind his back and was walking him toward the side exit when Tyler's friends started shouting, and one of them took a swing at Doyle, and the whole thing spilled out into the alley behind the Copper Line, under the one working floodlight, with Tyler on his knees in the gravel screaming that Doyle was a dead man and that his father would have this place shut down by Monday.

The 911 call came from the venue's bartender. Two units rolled. The first officer on scene was a patrolman named Eddie Fuentes, twenty-six, two years on the job, still new enough to believe in the manual. He found Tyler Voss with a split lip and gravel in his hair, shouting at Doyle, who stood with his hands up and his shirt torn, bleeding from the eyebrow scar. Fuentes did what he was trained to do: he separated them, he took names, he started the preliminary report on his hood with his flashlight. Then the second unit arrived, and out of it stepped Sergeant Reilly, and Reilly took one look at the scene and said, "Fuentes. A word." They walked ten feet down the alley, out of earshot of Doyle and the gathering crowd. Reilly said, "That's the chief's kid." Fuentes said, "He started it, Sarge. The bouncer's got witnesses." Reilly looked at him for a long moment. "What's the bouncer's name," he said. "Doyle," Fuentes said. Reilly nodded. "Here's what's going to happen. You're going to put the kid in your car and drive him home. You're going to tell the chief's wife he had a rough night. Doyle gets a warning for excessive force on a patron, and we all go home." Fuentes said, "Sarge, I can't — " and Reilly said, "You can. And you will. Because the alternative is I write you up for insubordination right here in this alley, and your probationary review is in August."

Fuentes drove Tyler home. He remembered the ride for years afterward: Tyler in the back seat, drunk and crying and then not crying, saying, "You know what I could do to you," and Fuentes saying nothing, watching the road. Mrs. Voss answered the door in a robe and thanked Fuentes like he'd done the family a kindness, and Fuentes went back to the precinct and sat in his cruiser in the lot for twenty minutes before he went inside. He filed the preliminary report the way Reilly told him to file it: disturbance, mutual, no arrests, parties separated. He left out the part about the alley conversation. He told himself it wasn't his fight. He told himself that for a long time.

Pete Hanlon, who owned the Copper Line, filed his complaint the following Tuesday. Hanlon was sixty-one, a former longshoreman who'd bought the venue with his settlement money after the container crushed his foot, and he didn't scare easy. He wrote that an off-duty officer's son — he didn't know whose son, not then — had assaulted his head of security, threatened to have the venue shut down, and been driven home by police while his employee was warned. He asked for an investigation. The complaint entered the system as IA 15-041. Hargrove read it standing up by the coffee machine. He called Reilly. Reilly said, "The kid was drunk. Doyle roughed him up. It's a misunderstanding." Hargrove said, "Write it up." The disposition letter went to Hanlon twenty-three days later, two paragraphs this time, which Hanlon took as a kind of respect until he read them: "The investigation found conflicting accounts of the incident. The evidence suggests a mutual misunderstanding arising from an overcrowded venue and alcohol consumption by multiple parties. No misconduct is substantiated. This case is closed." Hanlon called the number on the letterhead and asked to speak to someone about the part where the police drove the assailant home, and the woman who answered said she'd pass along his message, and nobody ever called back. Doyle quit the Copper Line that summer and took a job doing security at the port, where the pay was better and the drunks were at least strangers. Hanlon kept the letter in his office drawer. He showed it to a reporter once, years later, off the record, and the reporter said, "Jesus," and never wrote the story.

The third one happened in November, at Rocco's, the Italian place on Main Street with the red awnings where the Voss family had a standing reservation every other Friday and where the owner, Rocco Benedetti, kept a photograph of himself shaking the chief's hand behind the register. Eddie Salazar was twenty-four, a line cook, fast with a knife and good under pressure, the kind of kid who sent half his paycheck home to his mother in El Paso and never missed a shift. On a Friday night in the middle of the dinner rush, Tyler Voss sent his veal back twice. The first time, Eddie remade it without a word. The second time, Tyler came through the kitchen door — customers weren't allowed through the kitchen door, everyone knew that, but the door had no lock and Tyler had the look of a man who had never been told no in a room with a door — and stood at the pass with his plate in his hand and said, loud enough for the whole line to hear, "Are you stupid or just lazy." Eddie kept his eyes on the grill. He said, "I'll remake it, sir." Tyler set the plate down on the pass, hard, sauce jumping onto the white tile, and leaned in close enough that Eddie could smell the wine. "People like you," Tyler said, very quietly, "end up in the river. You understand me." Then he walked back out to his table, and the kitchen went back to work, and nobody said anything, because in a kitchen during a rush there is no time for anything except the next ticket.

News in the same category

Police Chief’s Son Dragged a Black Man Out of a Diner — Unaware He Was the New Mayor

30 Part