Marcus did not arrive with a cruiser or a camera crew. He arrived with Ruiz and a thermos of coffee, and he sat on the concrete beside Earl as if that were the most natural thing in the world for a chief of police to do.
"Mr. Simmons," Marcus said, "my name is Marcus Vance. I am the new chief here. I understand you had trouble near the station last winter."
Earl studied him for a long moment. The rain had eased to a drizzle, and water dripped from the girders above them in a slow, patient rhythm.
"Trouble is a polite word for it," Earl said at last. "I was sleeping. That is all. I was sleeping on a bench near the station because the shelter had a flu outbreak and they turned folks away. An officer woke me up with his boot. Not a shake. A kick. When I sat up too slow for him, he dragged me off the bench and put me face down on the wet concrete. My shoulder has not been right since."
"Do you remember the officer?" Ruiz asked gently.
Earl smiled, but there was no humor in it. "I remember his voice. He told me the station was not a hotel and that veterans like me gave real soldiers a bad name. He took my bag and threw it in a dumpster. My discharge papers were in that bag. My medicine, too. I went to file a complaint the next day. The man at the desk told me to come back when I was sober. I was sober. I just looked like I was not."
Marcus felt a familiar, cold anger settle in his chest, the kind he had learned in Chicago to hold still and use rather than let it use him. He did not interrupt. He let Earl finish, and when Earl finished, Marcus asked the question that mattered most.
"Would you be willing to tell that story again, on the record, to Captain Ruiz? Not to a desk sergeant. To her."
Earl looked at the thermos, at Ruiz's notebook, at the rain. "Son," he said, "I have told that story to three different people in uniforms. Nothing happened. Why would this time be different?"
"Because this time," Marcus said, "the man who heard it first is not going to be the man who decides whether it counts. And because I am not asking you to trust the department. I am asking you to trust that I will sit here until you are finished, and then I will do the work myself if I have to."
Earl was quiet for a while. Then he nodded, once, and began again from the beginning, slower this time, with dates and details he had memorized because no one else had bothered to write them down. Ruiz wrote without hurrying him. When he described the night his shoulder was injured, his voice did not shake. When he described losing his papers, it did, just a little.
Before they left, Marcus gave Earl his direct number, written on a plain card with no seal and no title, only a name and a phone number. "If anyone from this department comes to you and tells you to forget this," Marcus said, "you call me. Day or night."
Earl tucked the card into the inside pocket of his coat, where it would stay dry. "You are a strange kind of chief," he said.
"I have been told that before," Marcus said.
On the walk back to the car, Ruiz said, "He is not the only one who slept near that station and regretted it. There are two more names in the complaint log that were closed as unfounded within forty-eight hours. Same officer description. Same bench."
"Get them," Marcus said. "And get the medical records if they will sign for them. We do not build this on anger. We build it on paper that cannot be argued away."
The second victim was seventeen, and his mother did most of the talking at first because she was afraid that if she stopped, she would start crying and not be able to start again.
Darius Cole lived with his mother, Denise, in a small apartment above a laundromat on the east side of Belleville. He was tall for his age, thin, with a careful way of moving that suggested he had learned early how to make himself smaller in rooms where he did not feel safe. He wore a school sweatshirt and kept his hands in his pockets while his mother set out glasses of water on a kitchen table that was too small for three adults and a teenager.
"He was walking home from basketball practice," Denise said. "It was not late. It was barely dark. Two officers stopped him on the corner of Eighth and Pine. They said he fit a description. They never said a description of what."
Darius looked down at the table. "They made me empty my pockets on the sidewalk," he said, his voice low but steady. "My keys, my wallet, my practice jersey. Then one of them took my phone. He said he needed to check it for gang contacts. I told him there was nothing like that on there, just my school stuff and pictures of my little sister. He dropped it. On purpose. He stepped on it when he handed it back, like it was an accident, but he looked right at me when he did it."
"Which officer?" Ruiz asked.
Darius hesitated. Denise put a hand over his, not to hurry him, but to anchor him.
"The big one," Darius said. "Miller. I heard the other one call him that. The other one looked embarrassed. He kept saying, 'Come on, man, the kid is clean.' Miller told him to shut up and write it up as a field interview."