On the drive back to the precinct, Marcus was silent for several blocks. Finally he said, "Doyle is not a bystander. He is the system that lets Miller work."
"Doyle has been at the 12th for twenty-three years," Ruiz said. "He signs off on Miller's reports. He signs off on the overtime. He was the sergeant on duty the night your bodycam file was accessed. And according to Patel's notebook, he was the man who collected when Miller was not there."
Marcus looked out at Warren Avenue, at the shuttered storefronts and the people hurrying through the drizzle with their collars up. "Then Doyle is our next interview," he said. "But not yet. First, we finish hearing from the people Doyle never listened to."
Angela Torres was the fourth person they visited, and her story was the one Marcus already knew in outline, because it had begun before he arrived in Belleville and had continued, in whispers, after his beating at the station made the local news in a way the department had not intended.
Angela worked nights as a home health aide, and she had called the police twice in the spring when a former partner threatened her at her apartment door. Both times, Miller had been among the responding officers. Both times, according to Angela, he had spent more time questioning her immigration status, her work hours, and why she was out so late than he had spent looking for the man who had threatened her. The second time, she said, he told her that women who invited trouble should not be surprised when it found them.
"I stopped calling," Angela told Ruiz, sitting at her kitchen table with her hands wrapped around a mug she did not drink from. "I told my sister, if something happens, call the shelter, not the police. That is a terrible thing to have to teach yourself, but I learned it."
Marcus, who had heard versions of that sentence in Chicago more times than he cared to count, asked her what she needed now. Not what the department needed. What she needed.
"I need to know that if I call again, someone different will come," Angela said. "And I need that officer to be gone, not just moved to another precinct where he can do the same thing to someone else's sister."
"We are not moving him," Marcus said. "We are building a case that ends his career in law enforcement. That takes longer than a transfer, and it is harder, but it is the only outcome that means anything."
Angela nodded, and for the first time, she drank from the mug. "Then I will sign," she said. "But I want a copy of everything I sign. I have learned to keep copies."
"You will have them," Ruiz promised, and she meant it.
That evening, Marcus went to a community meeting he had not called, because Pastor James Whitfield had called it, and Marcus had learned long ago that a chief who only attended his own meetings would never hear the truth.
The meeting was held in the fellowship hall of Whitfield's church, a warm, plain room with folding chairs, a coffee urn that hissed, and a bulletin board covered in flyers for food drives, tutoring, and a youth basketball league that Darius Cole had once played in. About sixty people came, which Whitfield said was more than usual, and they did not come to praise the new chief. They came to test him.
Whitfield, a tall man in his sixties with a voice that could fill a sanctuary without a microphone, opened the meeting with prayer and then with plain speech. "We have had chiefs before," he said, looking directly at Marcus, who sat in the second row rather than on the platform. "We have had promises before. We have had task forces and listening sessions and reports that went into drawers. So forgive us if we do not applaud yet. We are here to see if you will still be here when the applause stops."
Marcus stood when Whitfield invited him to speak, and he did not use notes. He told the room, without naming names that were still under investigation, that the department had a pattern of complaints that disappeared, of overtime that did not match patrol logs, and of officers who treated certain streets as their own territory. He told them about Earl Simmons, with Earl's permission, and about the notebook Patel had kept. He did not tell them about the missing bodycam file, because Ruiz had advised him that the investigation would be stronger if the people who took it did not yet know how much he knew about how it was taken.
A woman in the third row, a mother named Carla Bennett whose son had been stopped three times in one month, stood up. "Chief, with respect, my boy is afraid to walk to school. What do you tell a mother whose son is afraid of the people who are supposed to keep him safe?"
Marcus met her eyes. "I tell you that your son's fear is evidence, not exaggeration. And I tell you that I will not ask you to trust me. I will ask you to watch what happens in the next thirty days, and judge me by that. If Miller is still wearing a badge in this city at the end of that time, you will have your answer about me."